Home Blog Page 236

“The Homeland of the Turks: The North of the Caspian Sea”

The Origin of Turkish and Turks Conference was Held at Kirikkale University

Ege University faculty member Prof. Dr. Osman Karatay gave a conference on ‘The Origin of Turkish and Turks’ at our University. Academicians and students showed great interest in the event organized by the Turan Peoples Research Group in the Yahya Kemal conference hall.

Contributing to important studies on Turkish history, Prof. Dr. Karatay opposed the idea that the homeland of the Turks, which was put forward for political purposes, was the Altai Mountains, with scientific data. Prof. Dr. Karatay said, “Many scholars share the same ideas about the origin and homeland of the Turks. They state that Turks in general originated in northern China, around Mongolia. So, where did the idea that the homeland of the Turks is the Altai Mountains around Mongolia, the idea of ​​Turkishness and Mongolism being side by side? The emergence of this idea dates back to the 1873 Congress of Orientalists. A decision has been made regarding this idea and studies are underway to fill that decision. Since then, the idea has been put forward that the homeland of the Turks is not even the Altai Mountains, but somewhere further east, on the shores of the Pacific Ocean.

Prof. Dr. Osman Karatay stated that words can pass from one language to another as a result of cultural, political and commercial relations in every period of history, and said, “We see that there are almost no Chinese words in Old Turkish. In this case, either there was no interaction with China or it was formed in a place far from China in the Turkish formation era.

162 of the 310 foreign words identified in Pre-Turkish belong to Sanskrit, the ancient language of today’s Indians. The common ancestors of the Indians and Iranians, the Aryans, lived in the Romanian-Ukraine region, in the Ariana country. The fact that so many words are in Turkish shows that the Arians and Turks were in close relations in ancient times. When we examine the history of the Turks and Aryans, we can say that the geography that allows this neighborhood relationship is the region of the Caspian Sea.

Chinese, Greek, Roman Sources Reveal North of Caspian Sea

Stating that Greek and Roman historians such as Herodotus, Plinius and Pomponius mention a nation living in the upper regions of the Caspian Sea with the names Turcae, Tyrcae, Iurcae, Thyssagetae in their texts, Prof. Dr. Karatay said, “The text we read today as Ergenekon Epic is included in two Chinese yearbooks, Co-şu and Su-şu, written in the Göktürk period, the first sentence of which was taken without being translated into Turkish. In the first sentence of one of those texts, he says, ‘The ancestral home of the Göktürks is on the right bank of the West Sea’. In the other, there are expressions ‘in the upper part of the western sea’. Why did our teachers ignore these texts? “These texts show that the ancestors of the Göktürks came from the north of the Caspian Sea, which the Chinese refer to as the Western Sea,” he said.

Prof. Dr. Karatay pointed out that a large Turkish population is needed to write the history of the Turks, who established many states in different geographies of the world and left important traces, and said, “This Turkish population could not have arisen in unproductive, arid lands. Turkishness must emerge in fertile lands. The Altai Mountains region is one of the driest places in the world. Agriculture and animal husbandry are not allowed. Grassy and forested areas are very scarce. A people that originated in the Altai mountains or the Mongolian steppes cannot reach the number that can play the role of Turkishness in history. “Geodemography shows us that this is not possible,” he said.

Addressing the subject through plant names in Turkish, Prof. Dr. Osman Karatay said, “The number one method in ethnicity research in the world is to look at the plant names in that language. Turkish is a language with its own agricultural terms. We did not take barley, rye or wheat from other languages. This means that the ancestors of the Turks were not completely nomadic and there were some who were engaged in agriculture.

In the light of this information, there are three regions in Eurasia that are likely to be homelands. The Manchuria Plain is the Fergana Valleys, that is, the environs of today’s Uzbekistan, and the Southern Ural area, which is located in the north of the Caspian Sea and a little east of the north.

Words in Turkish point to cold climate plants. There are no words for peach, apricot or zerdali in Turkish. We got it from Persian because these are the fruits of the warm region, they do not grow in the north, but we grow apples, walnuts, plums. These show us that the ancient Turks were engaged in agriculture in a cold region. Therefore, it cannot be Fergana. It can’t be on the east side either, because if there were, there would be a lot of Mongolian, Chinese, words in Turkish.

“The only place we have left is the north of the Caspian Sea,” he said.

Stating that the researches and excavations carried out in the north of the Caspian Sea, the region has an important cultural development and that this culture spread to Central Asia in time, Prof. Dr. Karatay stated that those who do not want to bring the words ‘Turk, culture and civilization’ side by side are trying to show the primitive, undeveloped places of the period as the homeland of the Turks for some political purposes.

Answering the questions of the audience after the speech, Prof. Dr. To Osman Karatay, advisor to the Turan Peoples Research Society, Assoc. Dr. Seyfullah Yalın presented a plaque. At the end of the program, Prof. Dr. Osman Karatay signed his books for our students.

https://kku.edu.tr/Anasayfa/Haber/Index/511

 

 

Uyghurs in China: Sean Roberts SDSU Book Talk

Ahmet T. Kuru
@dr_ahmetkuru

Literature on Ukraine in Turkey National Library

https://kasif.mkutup.gov.tr/OpacArama.aspx?Ara=ukrayna&DtSrc=0&fld=-1&NvBar=0

Literature on Crimea in Turkey National Library

https://kasif.mkutup.gov.tr/OpacArama.aspx?Ara=KIRIM&DtSrc=0&fld=-1&NvBar=0

Turkey and Crimea of Ukraine

The Crimean War: A History
by Orlando Figes | Feb 28, 2012

The Russo-Turkish War, 1768-1774: Catherine II and the Ottoman Empire
by Brian L. Davies (Author)

 

The Crimean War: Then and Now Hardcover – January 23, 2018
by Dr David R Jones (Author)

The Crimean War: The History and Legacy of the Conflict that Modernized Warfare and Weakened Tsarist Russia Paperback – January 4, 2019
by Charles River Editors (Author)

The Origins of the Crimean War (Origins Of Modern Wars) 1st Edition
by David M. Goldfrank (Author)

Debar Śepatayim: An Ottoman Hebrew Chronicle from the Crimea (1683-1730). Written by Krymchak Rabbi David Lekhno Hardcover – August 17, 2021
by Rabbi David Lekhno (Author), Yaron Ben-Naeh (Author), Dan Shapira (Author), Aviezer Tutian (Author)

The Jews of Khazaria Paperback – December 16, 2009
by Kevin Alan Brook (Author)

Khazaria in the Ninth and Tenth Centuries (East Central and Eastern Europe in the Middle Ages, 450-1450)
by Boris Zhivkov (Author)

The Routledge Handbook of the Crimean War 1st Edition
by Candan Badem (Editor)

Letters Written From Turkey And The Crimea, 1854 (1870) Hardcover – October 27, 2008
by Henry Aldworth Neville (Author), Grey Neville (Author)

Eastern Tourkia, Khazaria

Map: Khazar Khaganate, 650–850

Byzantine sources refer to Hungary as Western Tourkia in contrast to Khazaria, Eastern Tourkia. 

The Byzantines called Khazaria Tourkía, and by the 9th century referred to the Khazars as “Turks”

The Khazars[a] (/ˈxɑːzɑːrz/) were a semi-nomadic Turkic people that in the late 6th-century AD established a major commercial empire covering the southeastern section of modern European Russiasouthern UkraineCrimea, and Kazakhstan.[10] They created what for its duration was the most powerful polity to emerge from the break-up of the Western Turkic Khaganate.[11] Astride a major artery of commerce between Eastern Europe and Southwestern Asia, Khazaria became one of the foremost trading empires of the early medieval world, commanding the western marches of the Silk Road and playing a key commercial role as a crossroad between China, the Middle East and Kievan Rus’.[12][13] For some three centuries (c. 650–965) the Khazars dominated the vast area extending from the Volga-Don steppes to the eastern Crimea and the northern Caucasus.[14]

  • Tourkia (Khazaria) (“eastern Tourkia”), designation for the early medieval Khazar state in Byzantine sources
  • Tourkia (Hungary) (“western Tourkia”), designation for the medieval Hungarian state in Byzantine sources

The Byzantine Constantine Porphyrogennetos called Árpád “ho megas Tourkias archon” (the great prince of Tourkia),[52] and all of the 10th-century princes who ruled the country held this title.[5] Peter B. Golden, Nomads and their neighbours in the Russian steppe: Turks, Khazars and Qipchaqs, Ashgate/Variorum, 2003.

“Tenth-century Byzantine sources, speaking in cultural more than ethnic terms, acknowledged a wide zone of diffusion by referring to the Khazar lands as ‘Eastern Tourkia’ and Hungary as ‘Western Tourkia.‘” Carter Vaughn Findley, The Turks in the World History Archived 5 February 2016 at the Wayback Machine, Oxford University Press, 2005, p. 51, citing Peter B. Golden, ‘Imperial Ideology and the Sources of Political Unity Amongst the Pre-Činggisid Nomads of Western Eurasia,’ Archivum Eurasiae Medii Aevi 2 (1982), 37–76.

Bipolar World Siege upon the Key of the World: Turkey

American Cars in Istanbul Turkey in 1975

Copyright of photos by Levent Ağaoğlu

 

Gözler, Gökler

Gözler, Gökler

Yinçü Ögüz aşıldı
Şantung balıka
Talay ögüzke tegdi
Aşılanlar, ulaşılanlar
İlkler yaşandı

Yaşananlar
Taşa yazıldı
Yaşadı Yazdı
Çağları dağları aştı
Bugüne taştı

Gözler yaşardı
Gökler boşandı
Bozkırlar yeşerdi
Ekinler göverdi
Sevdalar yaşandı

Batı Doğu
Kuzey Güney
Yönler şaştı
Taşın döndü başı
Yazılınca Yönlendi

Ben’ler, Sen’ler
Onlar, Binler
Biz’ler
Şaştı kaldı

Bilge’miz dendi
Hem Kaleme
Hem Kılıça
E  f  e  n  d  i
E f e l e n d i

Levent Ağaoğlu
22 Ekim 2019

NOTLAR:
Yinçü-ögüz (İnci nehri=Seyhun=Sir-derya)

teg- 1. (yönelme durumuyla) değmek, ulaşmak, erişmek 2. (savaşta) hücum etmek, saldırmak 3. (yaş sözüyle) yaşı kemale ermek, yaşlanmak 4. (küni sözüyle) yüksek bir unvan almaya hak kazanmak

İki birig ertimiz. İki sümüz boldı. Türk budun kılınğalı Türk kağan olurğalı Şantung balıkka talay ögüzke tegmiş yok ermiş. Kağanıma ötünüp sü iltdim.

İki bin idik. İki ordumuz oldu. Türk milleti kılmalı, Türk kağanı oturalı Şantug şehrine, denize ulaşmış olan yok imiş. Kağanıma arz edip ordu gönderdim.

Bilge Tonyukuk Yazıtı, MS 720, Tola Irmağı, Moğolistan

Ukraine Issue of Karam Periodical from Turkey

http://www.karamdergisi.com/English/OncekiSayilarDetay.aspx?Sayi=41

 

 Sayı

Editor
Osman Karatay-Mehmet Seyfettin Erol

Assistant Editor
Umut Üren

Ankara  2014

Generic File  | Cover  | Index  | Editor’s Note


Mehmet Seyfettin Erol  
“Ukrayna-Kırım Krizi” Ya da “İkinci Yalta Süreci” Ss, 1-14
The Ukraine-Crimea Crisis or the Second Yalta Process

Özet | Abstract | Ful Text(Pdf) |
Oktay Bingöl  
Ukrayna Krizinin Ulusal, Bölgesel-Küresel Bağlamı ve Gelecek Öngörüleri Ss, 15-38
National and Regional-Global Context of the Crisis in Ukraıne and Perspectives for Future

Özet | Abstract | Ful Text(Pdf) |
Ali Servet Öncü  
Türkiye ve Ukrayna İlişkilerinin Başlaması ve İlk Yılları Üzerine Genel Bir Bakış (1991-1994) Ss, 39-60
Commencement of Turkey-Ukraine Relations and an Overview of the First Years (1991-1994)

Özet | Abstract | Ful Text(Pdf) |
Erhan Akdemir  
Avrupa Birliği’nin Ukrayna Politikası: Eski Komşu Mu? Yeni Aday Mı? Ss, 61-75
The Ukrainian Policy of the EU: Previous Neighbor or New Candidate?

Özet | Abstract | Ful Text(Pdf) |
Yelda Demirağ  
The European Union’s Black Sea Policy: In Light of Recent Developments Ss, 76-86
The European Union’s Black Sea Policy: In Light of Recent Developments

Özet | Abstract | Ful Text(Pdf) |
Göktürk Tüysüzoğlu  
Karadeniz Havzası’ndaki Çatışma Gerçekliğinin Güvenlikleştirme Yaklaşımı Çerçevesinde Anlamlandırılması Ss, 87-109
Making Sense of the Reality of Conflict in the Black Sea Basin Within the Context of the Theory of Securitization

Özet | Abstract | Ful Text(Pdf) |
Dünya Başol (Çıkuan)   
Volgograd Saldırıları, Soçi Olimpiyatları ve Kafkasya Ss, 110-126
The Volgograd Attacks, Sochi Olympics and the Caucasus

Özet | Abstract | Ful Text(Pdf) |
Lokman Erdemir  
Rusya’da Esir Bir Zâbit Vekili ve Esaret Günlüğü: Hafız Şaban Efendi Ss, 127-146
A Captivated Ottoman Officer in Russia: Hafız Şaban and His Captivity Diaries

Özet | Abstract | Ful Text(Pdf) |
Abdullah Özdağ  
Son Sadrazamlardan Hüseyin Hilmi Paşa Hakkında Bir Değerlendirme (1855-1923) Ss, 147-159
An Evaluation of Hüseyin Hilmi Paşa, One of the Last Grand Viziers (1855-1923)

Özet | Abstract | Ful Text(Pdf) |
– Selçuk Demir  
XVII. Yüzyılın Ortalarına Doğru Kelkid Kazası Ss, 160-179
The District of Kelkid in the Mid-17th Century

Özet | Abstract | Ful Text(Pdf) |
Mustafa Bayar  
Şebinkarahisar Yöresinde Ziyaret Yerleri ile İlgili İnanç ve Uygulamalar Ss, 180-207
Believes and Costumes Concerning Sacred Places in the Şebinkarahisar District

Özet | Abstract | Ful Text(Pdf) |
Faruk Doğan  
Temettuat Defterlerine Göre Tanzimat Döneminde Bir Trakya Kasabası: Pınarhisar- Pınarhisar Ss, 208-225
Pınarhisar: A Thracian Town According to the Tanzimat Era Temettuat Records

Özet | Abstract | Ful Text(Pdf) |
Behice Varışoğlu – İzzet ŞEREF- Mehmet GEDİK- İsa YILMAZ  
Deyim ve Atasözlerinin Öğretilmesinde Görsel Bir Araç Olarak Karikatürlerin Başarıya Etkisi Ss, 226-242
The Effect of Cartoons as a Visual Tool in the Success of Teaching Idioms and Proverbs

Özet | Abstract | Ful Text(Pdf) |
İvan Pavlii  
СПЕЦИФИКА СИНТАКСИЧЕСКИХ ТРАНСФОРМАЦИЙ ПРИ ПЕРЕВОДЕ СЛОЖНОПОДЧИНЁННЫХ ПРЕДЛОЖЕНИЙ В СЛАВЯНО-ТЮРКСКОМ ХУДОЖЕСТВЕННОМ ПЕРЕВОДЕ (НА МАТЕРИАЛЕ УКРАИНСКО-АЗЕРБАЙДЖАНСКОГО ПЕРЕВОДА) Ss, 243-249
Peculiarities of Syntactic Transformations in Translating Complex Sentences in Slavic-Turkic Literary Translations (Based on the Material of Ukrainian-Azerbaijani Translation)

Özet | Abstract | Ful Text(Pdf) |
Muvaffak Duranlı  
Book Presentation and Evaluation: Opisanie Çernogo Morya, Egeyskogo Arhipelaga i Osmanskogo Flota Ss, 250-254
Description of the Blacksea, Aegean Archipelago and Ottoman Fleet

Özet | Abstract | Ful Text(Pdf) |
Didem Çatalkılıç  
Book Presentation and Evaluation: Seyahatü’l Kübra Ss, 255-259
Seyahatü’l Kübra

Özet | Abstract | Ful Text(Pdf) |