Home Blog Page 291

Turkey Top 10 Concepts: Heart

Heart (Gönül): The one in the heart (skin)
Shirt (Gönlek): A shirt that is worn outside the body.

The heart is the person himself, it is himself that he is dealing with. It is a concept that has existed since the Inscriptions of Inner Asia. The person shares his/her loneliness in the steppe with himself, the person who is himself/herself is the heart. When the heart is expressed as my heart, it is a person other than the person himself, he is also a confidant, a complicit, but another person. By multiplying himself as a heart, the person prevents othering others and seeing them as the other.

In Kutadgu Bilig, the first written work of the Turks, the heart is the decision maker, the decision should be made with the heart. The expression in Kutadgu Bilig is “first consult your heart, then consult, if you don’t like it, don’t get into that job” (KB. 3688-89.b.). Again in the same work, there is the determination that “a person’s heart is like a sea without a bottom, knowledge is like a pearl at its bottom, it is useless unless you remove it” (Kutadgu Bilig.211-212.b.).

The two dimensions of the Heart in question here are eternity and the knowledge it contains. So the heart is an endless source of knowledge. Finally, the expression “the reluctant man is only a shape and form: the reluctant man loses the name of the wise” (KB 2798.b) reveals that the way to wisdom passes from the heart, to having a heart.

The heart is the armor of the person that protects the person. The heart is a treasure that it hides inside. A person sees with the eyes of the heart what the eyes cannot see. The Turks, who managed to keep the world order in balance with the state and the universal state, have also placed their inner world in a solid balance with their hearts and eyes. The measure is the consent of the heart, the consent of the heart.

Turks are involved in at least seven religions, and they have always seen with their heart’s eyes and acted voluntarily in their religions. Inscriptions written with the belief in the sky god, the texts written with the belief of Buddhism that followed, for example, the philosophical texts of Vapşı Bakşı, which are completely heart-based, Taoism, Confucianism, Zoroastrianism, Manichaeism, Judaism and Christianity, the texts of Turks from Karaman, Cappadocia, from Khorasan. The texts of the Sufi knowledge starting from the beginning are all heart-centered texts. Along with the concept of heart, which is not found in any other language, Turks have also influenced and enriched the understanding and religion of the tribes in their geographies.

In the western understanding, the person himself becomes competent as an individual. In the Turkish understanding, the person himself is enriched with his heart. Thus, while the Western individual becomes more and more lonely, the heart seeks and finds compatibilists and is in contact with other hearts. Turks are nomadic-centered communities. While migrating, watching the sky with their eyes all night long, they wander the sky with the eyes of the heart and enrich their hearts and people with the power and inspiration they get from the heavens, the eye here is the eye of the heart.

The concept of heart has no equivalent in other languages. The concept of heart cannot be translated to the West, and the concept of philosophy to our language. Wisdom is what matters to us. A philosopher is a person who loves the sages. What the West understands from Wisdom is Lawrence.

“The expression of the concepts of love and affection in separate words is a richness granted to a limited number of languages. Turkish is one of them.” Teoman Durali

 

Copyright of Photograph by Levent Ağaoğlu, 1975
Copyright by Levent Ağaoğlu

Turkey Top 10 Concepts: The Original Spirit of the Turk- Sky and Heart

Our soul;

Nine Eight

It was our first target

Blue skies

Navy blue sea;

Mediterrenean!

 

April 16, 2018

Among the concepts that shape our soul, the most important ones are the concepts of sky and heart, which are the most processed and spoken. The sky is above us when we raise our heads, it has seven layers and is full of secrets. Due to the vastness and obscurity of the sky, the inefficiency of the geography and the place where the Turks set their feet, the Turks became the focus of attention. Whatever comes from the sky. They called themselves the Göktürks, they named the wise people as Gökçin bearded, and the wolf that guided them became legendary as Gökbörü. The sky is what the eye sees and is the symbol of eternity.

Another concept, the heart, is a bottomless sea and contains treasures of knowledge. It is the heart that rises to the sky. The heart is an eye that looks inward, seeking treasures of knowledge in the bottomless seas. It is the essence of man in the heart, it is man himself. Wealth is in the heart, it is the wealth of the heart. Rich people are those who carry the vastness of the sky to the depths of their hearts, and those who share the richness of the sky and heart with others in their eyes.

The spirit of the Turk wanders in the skies and in the hearts. He is the one who walks on the seas, He is the one who unites the hearts. The spirit of the Turk has continuously developed and moved to the next level, progressed and refined on the way to becoming competent. First of all, we come across five of the seven concepts in the Oguz Kagan epic.

In the period of the inscriptions belonging to the eighth century, we see that the majority of the concepts in the inscriptions of Bilge Tonyukuk, Bilge Kagan and Kul Tigin are included in the texts. When we come to the period of writings, we see that all seven of the concepts are mentioned in both Farabi and Yunus Emre.

The majority of the concepts are also mentioned in the works of Irk Bitig, Kutadgu Bilig, Divanı Lugat it Türk, Divanı Hikmet and Vapşı Bakşı. This inclusiveness shows that the spirit constantly refines and empowers itself in Turks.

The globalization process, which started with the opening of China to the world after the death of the Chinese leader Mao (September 9, 1976) in the last quarter of the 20th century, accelerated with the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989. China, which was the biggest reason for the start of the process, this time, towards the end of the first quarter of the 21st century, has caused the end of the globalization process as of 2020. The globalization process, which was called the “End of History” by the American scientist Francis Fukuyama and designed with the thought of ending time, could not even complete a fifty-year period, let alone a century. Especially as a result of the indifference of the European Union and the USA to the coronavirus process, the idea of ​​unity has lost its meaning in both continents.

The starting point of the book is about the plans to destroy human beings by artificializing during the corona virus epidemic in the early 2020s. Disappearing humanity has begun to threaten individual humans as well. It will be seen that the importance given to “human” among Turks, as of 2020, at the very beginning of the 21st century, has features that will put our country forward in the human hurricanes we live in and on our borders.

While the state founded by Atatürk, who invited the Western countries that attacked Turkey in the early 1920s to comply with human values ​​and recognize our sovereignty, sent aid convoys to the West in 2020, 100 years later, the human being is faced with the dilemma of extinction by being artificialized. has left. Disappearing humanity has begun to threaten individual humans as well.

The phrase “Budun da Budun boldi” (People also became people), which was first used by the Turks in the Tonyukuk Inscription (720 AD), was the   first example of how the people were elevated to where they should be. Turks have always demonstrated what they have lived and created (culture, language, states, etc.) The main thing in the Turks’ Epic of Creation and Oguz Kagan Epic was Human with all its universal reality.

A total of seven concepts, starting with the Person and ending with the Power, offer an inclusive field to explain the soul of the Turkish people. This area, on the other hand, is a large area, because it is the field where the soul of man is shaped. It is a unique Spirit; When we examine epics, inscriptions and writings, we always come across them in detail.

Our soul, which started to take shape as 9/8 in Rumelia starting from the 14th century, is a lively and enthusiastic musical rhythm. The roots of our soul, which once again caught universality in Rumeli, were shaped in the depths of inner Asia with the seven concepts here. This soul has three main elements: sky, earth and person. All three are created. A person’s life on earth, which is the world in question, is connected with the heavens, that is, the celestial universe shapes the person during his life.

From this point of view, the steppes of Inner Asia and Asia Minor have been the vast spaces where the connection with the skies has been established, the source of thoughts of the people. The thoughts of the people also fed the thinkers. The Silk Road steppes in Inner Asia and the Cappadocia region and surrounding areas in Asia Minor were the areas where the richest works were produced on the Eskişehir, Ankara, Konya, Kırşehir, Niğde, Nevşehir line. The first examples that come to our minds were Yunus Emre, Mevlana, Hacıbektaş Veli, thinkers who grew up in the steppe.

Cappadocia, the middle point of Asia Minor, and the steppe and agricultural basin areas in the middle of Central Asia were the main centers of thought. The source thinkers, whom we consider as a reference in our work, always came from these fields in Central Asia. The nourishment of the sky, the sun and the moon, the rain and the breeze, made the person dynamic.

The Turks, who gained their sovereignty during the War of Independence in 1920, also witnessed the end of the globalization process, which disregarded the sovereignty of the states and tried to destroy them, during the biological warfare process in 2020, 100 years after this date. The name of the new process that has begun is the period of personalization, and individuals and states will begin to progress towards being themselves.

The process in which people were depersonalized, states lost their sovereignty, became obscure, and was constructed towards the One World State, came to an end. In 2020, when we celebrate the 100th anniversary of our sovereignty, the projects of the West, which came to the fore with the Corona virus epidemic, of digital people, directing people to chip in with their consent are clear indications that the direction of reform has changed.

The task of reining the West’s longing and pressure for a world without humanity falls to the Turks this time. The residues of paganism and feudalism have now thoroughly dehumanized the West. The sects that were expelled from the religion of Christianity, cult sects and secret organizations that were reaped from the sects, all seek to impose a satanic order on the divine realm.

Copyright of Photograph by Levent Ağaoğlu, 1987, Damascus

Copyright by Levent Ağaoğlu

Turkey Top 10 Concepts: It is the sky on earth; Steppe..

The steppe mind is a collective way of thinking; is not singular but universal. The old Turks call it Ög. Ög multiplies, accumulates and diversifies by being added in each generation. This variety is then poured into phrases in the form of idioms and proverbs. In this respect, the Turkish language is the mirror of the Turkish mind. Ali Akar @ali_akar 24 Nov 2020

Steppe; is the sky on earth.

I could not reach the etymological data of the word Bozkır. When and where was it first used? Gök Börü is used as a Bozkurt, is there a similar situation here?

We have fought the Chinese for thousands of years inside the area where the Yellow River takes the shape of a bell. In the vicinity of Baotou on the top of Chiang, Tonyukuk was born.

“Yes, that region has served as a front-post for thousands of years for Turkish and other steppe peoples to advance into China. Tonyukuk’s exact birthplace is unknown, but he must have been around.” by Hayrettin İhsan Erkoç.@h_ihsan_erkoc Oct 30, 2020

The difference between steppe and desert..

“Farabi’s urban theory, unlike Ibn Khaldun’s urban theory, constructs a space “open to animals” and invites people to build themselves in nature. The Turkish intellectual, who accepted Ibn Khaldun’s city model, broke the animal-human-nature relationship.” lütfi bergen@BergenLutfi Mar 31

It is sad to forget the inscriptions (Yenisey, Orkhon, Altay) written on stone in the areas from Manchuria to Mongolia and Hungary, starting from 1500 years ago along the steppe belt, as if they were written on ice…

“The great steppe has been the biggest school of the nations it has hosted. The burning sun, freezing cold, deadly hurricanes, impassable mountains, impenetrable deserts have developed a will of steel in steppe people. Motun, Tonyukuk, Cengiz, Temür… these are the children of the steppe school.” Ali Akar@ali_akar · Jun 2, 2020

Silent testimonies of meteorites extending to eternity..

Of course, it makes sense with your testimony.

“I intend to contribute to the task of understanding and narrating this great corpus, which I started in 1995, with a new book called Witnesses of the Steppes. In the book, you will find the oldest but familiar memories of the Turks. I hope you enjoy reading it as much as I did while writing it.”  by Erhan AYDIN ​​@proferhanaydin · 26 Mar

If Bozkurt is Gök Börü, then Bozkır should actually be Gök Kır.

We see the sky in the countryside at the gates of the Divriği Great Mosque.

Finally…

 

Turkey Top 10 Concepts: Tengri-God

The first word identified in Turkish is Tengri (God). It is seen that Turks have strong beliefs and the conceptual framework is ancient and strong. Atheism would later jump to the Americas over the Yakut Turks. The Turks have also transformed the belief world of the Chinese with their belief in the Gods of Heaven.

Tengri is the old way of saying God in today’s Turkish. It is the first deciphered word in the Orkhon Inscriptions. Source: Issues of Göktürk history-Osman Fikri Sertkaya-page 130, Turkish Culture Research Institute, 1995 Ankara, 360 pages. Adnan Binyazar- 25 famous works in Turkish language (page 8), Varlık Publications, 263 pages, 1982

According to this belief, the supreme spirit of Heaven was Tengri. People used to feel safe among the spirits of Tengri, the sky father, Ötüken, the earth mother, and their ancestors who were protecting people, and prayed to them and other nature spirits.

Turks embraced the universe with their understanding of Tengri, or god. From the earliest times, they had a great belief that man was created. Again, as it is written in the Bilge Kagan Inscription, “God lives time, man was created mortal.” The first word Tengri, which was used for the first time in the Huns, later continued as “sky Tengri” in the Gök Turks. One of our living thinkers, Dr. Sait Başer published a study book on the similarity of Gök Tanrı and Allah’s attributes and identified many similarities in this regard. Here are the inscriptions on which it is based, the Göktürk Inscriptions.

The creation of Turks in Asia Minor and their expression of God as love is an important indicator of how comprehensive and inclusive Turkish theology is.

Ahmed Yasawi whispered from Turkistan:

“The carefree person is not the person; understand that.
Lightless human, animal species, listen to this.”

Âşık Pasha, who gave a voice from Anatolia:

Become Adami so that there is light in the moment.
[They say man, the one who is light]

The Turkish state gets its power by creation. The trinity of heaven, earth and man was first and foremost being created. The statements in the Bilge Kagan inscription “the man whose time lives are God is created and he is mortal” and the mention of the earth and the sky are the proofs of the advanced theology of the Turks. In addition, expressions such as “I won because God wanted” in the Bilge Tonyukuk inscription are indicators of the dominance attributed to the will of God.

Turks have had a deep belief that they were created since their existence. The first identified word of the Turks is the concept of tengri, it was determined from the Huns and they were extremely insistent on the subject of god, belief and theology. The Creator also showed himself as a soul in the person. The Turks described the soul as kut, it is bestowed on the person by the creator. Man is mortal and created. The level of divine awareness in Turks has always been high. The soul of the Turk has a wandering and nomadic character as a result of the constraints of the steppe geography. It is not dependent on the earth, but it is always connected with the sky.

In the 7K1N system, which we have identified as seven criteria, the concept of sky is in the first place and the concept of person is in the second place as the most frequently used criterion.

Thus, the message given by the Turks through epics, inscriptions and manuscripts is the inseparability of the creator and the created. The frequency of use of the words sky and god is at the forefront by far. The inscription, which includes the phrase “God lives time”, also includes the phrase “man is mortal”. The difference between man and god is the acts of being subject to time and living time. The importance that the Turks give to the person is like a divine concept. After Root (God), the concept of Person is used the most. It is understood that the theology of the Turks is very deep and powerful.

Copyright of Photo by Levent Ağaoğlu, 2003, Pecs, Hungary

Copyright by Levent Ağaoğlu,

@agaoglulevent

Turkey Top 10 Concepts: Public

Our name is sluggish
Who is our enemy?
We don’t hold grudges against anyone
Public world helps us

Yunus Emre

“The Ottoman rulers are followers of what the Göktürks said in the Orkun inscriptions. In the inscriptions, he says, I dressed him when I was naked, I fed him when I was hungry. That is the essence of the Ottoman system.” Prof Dr Mehmet Young Turkish Historiography. Ottoman Empire, 2nd Abdulhamid and Dardanelles War Ottoman Empire 13 May 2017, Ali Emiri Cultural Center.

The concept of state in the Arabs did not exist before Islam. In Turks, on the other hand, the State (boy-budun-töre-il sociology) has been alive for thousands of years; lives.
The concept of Public, which first appeared in Bilge Kagan and Kul Tigin inscriptions, also appears in Kutadgu Bilig and Divan-ı Lugat it Türk. The most intense usage is expressed with Yunus Emre, as in his own concept.

Turkish people give the same value to the public as they give to the individual. It is the same understanding from the Göktürks to the Ottomans. There should be no hungry people, beggars should not be found in the streets. The important thing in the town is to produce enough bread for the population. In the inscriptions, Bilge Kagan mentions that he clothed the naked people and fed the hungry. The Chinese Emperor was very surprised and could not understand this attitude of the Turkish Khan, who shared the spoils with his people.

According to the Turkish understanding of Khanate, the most important duty of the Khan is the peace, order and happiness of his people. Inscriptions, Kutadgu Bilig, Atabet ül Hakayık, and Political Works are always full of these examples. When it came to the Republic, the peasant was considered the master of the nation and heavy taxes on the people were abolished.

As a result of the relations of people, language and state structures, which are public assets, are enriched. Just as the root meaning of the concepts of water, wetness, life, death and creation in kiş (otter), which is at the root of the word person, the word il, which means the state, which is the highest public structure, also indicates relations.

The concept of state, which is expressed by the concept of state in the West, is a status quo and a static structure. The word dawlat, which comes from the Arabic root dwl, is taken from the word “1st fortune, luck, 2nd fortune, destiny, 3rd power, sovereignty”. In Arabic, on the other hand, the word Arabic dāla is the noun merre of the verb “turned, wandered (especially fate, kismet)”. (This word is synonymous with the Akkadian dālu verb “to turn around, to wander”.) Source: Sevan Nişanyan. Nisanyan Dictionary. https://www.nisanyansozluk.com/?k=state

In Turks, on the other hand, province, ambassador, district, communication are concepts related to the state and are based on the root relations in the term province. Relationships are not static, but rather dynamic. People create relationships. In the Turks, the public lives in the strongest form in the language. Since the oral culture is dominant, the accumulations in the language are kept fresh by being constantly updated. Relationships and communication are alive.

The mastery of the Turks in establishing a state is also expressed by the Greek professor Dimitri Kitsikis.

“Karamanlis was telling me that we Greeks are a very inept people to run a state. We have never had a state, what was established after 1821 is not a state, the Westerners managed to take advantage of us by establishing this state, we are colonies as you said. Yes, we are an empire people, but right now only our soul is the empire.

So, who is establishing a real state? Turks are setting up. He also told me that all great states were founded by Turks. They founded the Ottoman Empire. They established the Turkish-Mongolian Empire. Who even built Beijing? Did the Chinese do it? No, the Turkish-Mongols did. In China’s last dynastic war, who was victorious in China? The Manchuro-Turkish descendants were victorious. Turks know how to organize, they establish a state while we only have a state spirit.”  Source: Greek Turcologist Dimitris Kitsikis Explains Why Greece Should Unite With Turkey.. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NUcaaJKYsAg

The point that Prof. Dimitri Kitsikis sincerely admits is that the spiritual existence of the empire is not enough, and this must be done in practice, which the Turks actually did. What is at issue here is the power of organization, activating the spirit is possible with organization, this is also a public power, public power comes into play here. So it is this public power that the Greeks lack.

@agaoglulevent

Is UAE-Israel agreement a call for surrender for Palestine?

by Prof. Dr. Süleyman Kızıltoprak / Mimar Sinan Fine Arts University

Last 50 years’ events United Arab Emirates (UAE) witnessed both on its own history and the region’s history can be repeated in forthcoming 50 years.

With the exploration of petroleum about 60 years ago in United Arab Emirates (UAE), this poor region composed of small desert chiefdoms experienced a rapid transformation and turned into a modern state with respective high life qualities.

UAE’s warm relations with Israel behind closed doors were known. With recent expressions this sort of relations has been officialised and turned into an open form. However, the acceptance of an agreement between UAE and Israel on Palestinian territories is more important.

Short history of petroleum-oriented Emirates

With a territory of 77,700 kilometre squares, UAE is a convention of emirates born of petroleum. In early sixteenth century, the Ottoman Empire under the leadership of powerful Sultan Selim I took action in order to attain the goal of eliminating the threats of the Portuguese on the Arabian Peninsula and especially on the holy lands via Red Sea and Gulf of Basra and containing Iranian expansion on Ottoman Empire’s eastern frontiers. Sultan Selim I hindered the Portuguese by annexing holy and antique settlements such as Jerusalem, Damascus, Cairo, Mecca and Medina and assured the security of the Arabs of the region by gathering them under the same framework. Suleiman the Magnificent annexed Basra and Lahsa with the aim of chasing the Portuguese who were still threatening the Gulf of Basra and Arabian Peninsula. Thus, southern shores of the Gulf of Basra were secured. The situation was stabile in the Gulf of Basra until the arrival of Britain’s East India Company in the nineteenth century.

In 1820, several treaties were signed between littoral chieftains and the British on the security issues against the pirate attacks of the ships belonging to the British trade company and the utilisation of the ports in a safe way. In 1853, the parties reached a more detailed peace agreement in order to totally eliminate piracy. With this agreement the tribes known as “Littoral Emirates” or the “Emirates of Oman Coast” began to be called as “Trucial States” in English, “al Imarat al mutasaliha” in Arabic and “Antlaşmalı Emirlikler” in Turkish. By accepting this naming, Littoral Emirates turned into allied representatives of Britain in the region.

Against this British attempt, regional powers Ottoman Empire and Iran took action separately in order to protect their own interests. While Iran agitated the Shiites of the Gulf against Britain, Ottoman Empire increased its control on the region of Najd in 1871 and dominated the territories reaching till Qatar and declared that it did not recognise the British agreements with littoral chieftains of the Gulf of Basra.

In 1892, Britain attained a more comprehensive and more interest-oriented agreement with littoral chiefdoms. With this, the emirates remained free in their domestic affairs and became bound to British in security and foreign relations. The Ottoman Empire rejected all these agreements until 1914 and recognised the agreements between Britain and Gulf emirates that were signed just before the eruption of the First World War. Thanks to these agreements, the British secured their control on Oman coast and Gulf of Basra’s entry-exit points besides their continuing advantages in India. Despite recognising the independence of India in 1947 and retreating back from its ex-colony, Britain did not want to give up its supremacy on the emirates of Gulf of Basra and Oman coast.

On 30 March 1968, nine emirates including Bahrain and Qatar agreed on forming a union. However, Bahrain and Qatar decided on independence and left the union soon. With British approval and presence of a UN observer, Bahrain declared independence on 14 August 1971 followed by Qatar on 1 September 1971. Upon that, six of the littoral emirates or Trucial States as the British called, namely Abu Dhabi, Dubai, Sharjah, Ajman, Umm al Quwain, and Fujairah, assembled on 2 December 1971 and declared “al Imarah al Arabiyya al Muttahidah” (United Arab Emirates). Ras al Khaimah joined this federation in February 1972 as the seventh member. Abu Dhabi sheikh was appointed as president and Dubai sheikh as vice-president. Abu Dhabi was declared as temporary capital; however, it has remained so far. The decisions are taken on the basis of unanimity by the highest decision-making mechanism of the country, the seven-member Supreme Federal Council (al Majlis al aala li al ittihad). However, Abu Dhabi and Dubai have veto rights on all decisions. The president and vice-president of the union are elected by this council as well.

Petroleum gifted the coastal chiefdoms with state and population

With the exploration of petroleum about 60 years ago in United Arab Emirates (UAE), this poor region composed of small desert chiefdoms experienced a rapid transformation and turned into a modern state with respective high life qualities. Until joining the petroleum exporting countries in 1962, local chiefdoms had been busy only with pearl hunting, fishing and minor trade.

The emirates’ population was below 100,000 in 1960. This number rose to 180,000 in 1968, 558,000 in 1975, 1 million in 1980, 1.379 million in 1985, 2.938 million in 1999 and 8.264 million in 2010. UN estimates that the country’s total population was 9.771 million in mid-2019. According to UN data (2019), immigrants make up 87.9% of total population. Ethnic make-up of the population with 2015 estimates is: Emiratis 11.6%, Southern Asia 59.4% (India 38.2%, Bangladesh 9.5%, Pakistan 9.4%, others 2.3%), Egyptians 10.2 %, Philippines 6.1%, others 12.8%. Foreign population of the Emirates is affected by state policies in source countries and international developments. For instance, Indian population rose to 38% in 2015 up from 25% in 1985; whereas, Pakistani population went down from 13% to 9.4 % during the same period.

USA Relations

USA succeeded Britain in terms of UAE’s allegiance and dependency relations within time. Especially after the 11 September 2001 attack, UAE became the key partner of USA’s new policy in the region. With 308.5 billion dollars of export and 229.2 billion dollars of import according to 2017 data, UAE is one of the worst affected countries of the fluctuations in international markets as its main export items are petroleum and natural gas. This fact moves the government closer to USA. Indeed, as recent history suggests, this role contains great risks for UAE. While Iran was the greatest partner of the western world and the USA before 1980, this role shifted to Saddam-led Iraq after the revolution. After Saddam’s self-demolishment through his attack on Kuwait (at least through USA’s silence) and subsequent 11 September attack that led to his country’s invasion by USA, this role shifted to UAE and Saudi Arabia.

UAE engaged in continuous zigzags during the so-called Arab Spring; however, it did not leave the USA’s side. Recently, it has sided with Trump administration who claimed to end the centennial Arab-Israeli conflict via a “peace plan”.

Centennial Peace Plan or unconditional surrender to Israel?

Israel’s intentions toward strengthening its relations with Arab countries of the Gulf of Basra were known before. In recent years, hostility against Iran approached the parties. UAE and some Gulf countries did not hide their intentions toward a peace agreement with Israel. Compromise behind closed doors was uncovered with UAE’s peace memorandum. USA’s recognition of Jerusalem as the capital of Israel seemed to be approved by UAE. Annexation decision of West Bank seemed to postpone the date of the signing of the peace agreement with Israel. However, when the looks turned toward the explosion in Beirut Port, the time seemed appropriate for signing. Thus, UAE-Israel relations went further beyond from just anti-Iran alignment.

In return for Israel’s suspension of annexation of some parts of West Bank under invasion, UAE took action on 13 August 2020 Thursday in order to establish official relations with Israel. With a common memorandum of Israel, USA and UAE this step was highlighted as a “historical diplomatic breakthrough” that will bring peace to the Middle East. USA praised the “courage” of UAE and Israel for opening a new path that would “reveal the great potential in the region”.

Why did UAE sign a peace agreement with Israel?

For years, there had been an unmentioned military alliance between Israel and UAE and this was not secret. However, why is such an agreement attained now in an open way? The views that this agreement was the sole action that would stop Israel from annexing invaded territories in the West Bank were denied by the Palestinian side because the Emirates have never been present in the fore of the peace-making processes so far and have not had warm relations with Palestinian President Mahmud Abbas.

As known, Israel reached similar peace agreements with Egypt in 1989 and Jordan in 1994. Despite the fact that these agreements contained disadvantageous clauses for Arabs, there were certain gains for the mentioned countries to convince their own people as well. For example, Egypt re-took the Sinai Peninsula that had been lost in the war of 1967. Jordan also acquitted the stereotype of being the “scapegoat” who had supported Saddam against Israel.

UAE became the first Arabic Gulf country to declare official relations with Israel. Then what has UAE acquired with this agreement? An agreement on Palestinian territories means singling the Palestinian Arabs out. With this, Israel’s presence on invaded lands is recognised and even the decision of annexation is not rejected. Only Israel’s postponement of annexation decision in this phase is demonstrated as a gain.

The diplomatic appeal came after Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu’s decision of suspension of annexation of some parts of the invaded West Bank. This intention of agreement had been previously criticised by Arab countries and Europe. By claiming that this would permanently collapse the hopes for a Palestinian state alongside with Israel, EU and some Arab countries expressed that the status of Palestinians’ territories turned from invasion to annexation and added that the mentioned agreement ground meant the recognition of unrighteousness.

Trump proclaimed the agreement with his senior advisor Jared Kushner, USA’s Ambassador in Israel David Friedman and USA Foreign Ministry’s special representative for Iran affairs Brian Hook who is the pioneer of Trump Government’s maximum pressure campaign against Iran.

Although the agreement’s content is not exactly known, the “trusted ally” appraisals by USA seem to have sufficed for the UAE side. Netanyahu emphasised that although it was not an official peace agreement with Palestinians, the agreement between Israel and UAE was important to demonstrate the start of his country’s increasing acceptance in the region.

In Jerusalem, Netanyahu said “this shows the profound transformation we have achieved in Israel’s position in the Middle East”: “For decades, Israel had always been symbolised as an enemy. However, today many countries regard Israel as a strategic ally”.

This diplomatic agreement reflects the increasing anxiety that is common between Israel and Arabic Gulf countries on a potential conflict with Iran. Israel periodically hit the Iranian targets near the Syrian border. USA and its allies blamed Tehran for passing the narrow Hormuz Strait on Iran’s southern shores and attacking petroleum tankers en route the Gulf of Basra.

Trump told that Israeli and UAE leaders would visit the White House for a signing ceremony in proceeding weeks. The agreement contains direct flights, embassies and other bilateral deals. The Israeli and Emirati officials will meet soon for some bilateral arrangements as well. Including those who regard Iran as the source of instability in the Middle East, USA officials applauded the establishment of diplomatic relations between Israel and UAE.

USA’s special representative for Iran affairs Brian Hook’s usage of the word “Arabs” as one part of the agreement in his speech “the peace agreement between Arabs and Israelis is the worst nightmare of Iran” points out Bahrain and Oman and covertly Saudi Arabia along with UAE.

According to the claims from UAE side, Crown Prince Muhammad bin Zayed and other Emirati leaders decided to offer the normalisation agreement by believing that Israel’s annexation would annihilate the two-state solution and Israeli-Palestinian peace. In this line, bin Zayid said “during a conversation with President Trump and Prime Minister Netanyahu, an agreement was reached on stopping further Israeli annexation of Palestinian territories. Moreover, UAE and Israel came on terms on a roadmap to establish bilateral relations in cooperation”.

Israel’s gains, Arabs’ losses

To categorise the winning and losing sides on the basis of the content of the agreement:

  1. Trump Administration in USA acquires a positive image on the eyes of the electorate by providing positive contributions to peace process and Israel. This can be assessed as a well-timed political move by Trump to steal some wind from Biden’s sails before the elections.
  2. In Israel, Netanyahu can advertise himself as the “great statesman who successfully broke the Arab enmity circle”. This is a development that would enhance Netanyahu’s image which had been deteriorated after corruption allegations against him on air.
  3. UAE started to propagate itself as “the Arab country who signed peace to stop Israeli annexation”. However, Israel insists that it only temporarily suspended the annexation policy and did not permanently quit it.
  4. Were Palestinians present in any phase of the negotiations in any way? No, they were not. Did Palestinians support the “temporary” suspension of annexation? Palestinians provided no positive reactions for this agreement ever.
  5. How did the 22-member Arab League which had been founded in order to cooperate against Israel’s expansion on Arab lands and 57-member Islamic Cooperation Organisation (ICO) respond to this agreement? Despite an avowed reaction from Turkey, the silence of Egypt and Saudi Arabia is quite illustrative. From now on, Turkey’s leadership role will increase in regional politics and on Islamic countries while others’ role will decrease. Besides providing the most serious reaction to this agreement, as seen either inside the domestic borders or in the Eastern Mediterranean, Turkey’s moves on protecting its rights on sea by respecting the rights of the peoples of the region are appreciated by the international community, especially by the peoples of the region and ICO members. In addition to this, Turkey’s positive attitude toward the problems faced by the Middle Eastern countries, benevolence in humanitarian aid campaigns and utilisation of its military capacity as a deterring power in all events provide the most significant contribution to the ICO countries and the peoples of the region who expect a permanent and just peace instead of submissive policies concerning the Palestinian Question.
  6. Did UAE reserve its right to abolish the agreement in case of Israel’s suspension of the decision of stopping annexation? No, there is not such a statement. Conversely, Netanyahu asserted that they had temporarily suspended the decision of annexation. That is, the Israeli side can decide on a new annexation plan soon.

To sum up, this agreement means a rapid victory for Israel. Within time, Israel will normalise its relations with other Sunni Arab states as well and thus will attain more gains to increase its legitimacy on the territories it has invaded. With this agreement, Arabs will quit their goals to boycott and isolate Israel in international realm. From now on, the Palestinians will feel lonelier in their resistance against Israel and search new strategies to protect their lands. In this regard, the Middle Easter Question will not end; conversely, the multi-dimensional conflict system of the Middle East will become more sophisticated. This conflict will continue in a predictable future and permanent peace will not be attained.

Contrary to this, UAE’s ambassador in USA Yusuf Otaiba expects the arrival of peace to the region. According to him, this agreement is a significant breakthrough that “will diminish the tensions in Arab-Israeli relations, create a new energy for a positive change and immediately halt the annexation and violent confrontation potential”.

Let us see will it be so? Will Israel’s expansion strategy toward Palestinian, Lebanese, Syrian, Iraqi and Jordanian territories end? Will Israel give up its annexation policy after its completion of Jewish settlement building in the territories it has invaded? Will peace arrive in the region that has wiped blood and tears for centuries? Will the misfortune of the Iranian shah who lost his throne after establishing warm relations with USA and the Iraqi dictator Saddam spread to UAE?

Time will respond all these questions. However, UAE’s this decision points out the beginning of a new period in the Middle East and the Gulf of Basra. Last 50 years’ events UAE witnessed both on its own history and the region’s history can be repeated in forthcoming 50 years.

@suleymankzltprk

Source: https://www.aa.com.tr/tr/analiz/bae-israil-anlasmasi-filistin-e-teslim-ol-cagrisi-mi/1948738

 

 

 

 

 

 

Great Actor of Humor and Emotion: Şener Şen

In an interview with him on a TV channel, Şener Şen explains how he became an actor:

‘People may think: My father is Ali Şen and they may believe because he encouraged me to act. But this is not real. I had very good relations with my father. We used to talk about many topics. But we never talked about acting. My father never said my son be a theater actor, never a movie actor. He left me alone. May God have mercy on him, he was neither a support nor a hindrance. I became an actor by my own effort, struggling and learning.’

Giovanni Scognamillo describes his indefatigable energetic work in these words:

“He is active in his works, almost plays tricks when he is excited, goes into fits, goes mad, throws himself to the ground, jumps, jumps, runs; When he gets into a fight, it’s hard to suppress him and some of his actions and reactions are full of surprises. He is a cute and friendly turkey at the same time, he seizes opportunities, creates opportunities and knows how to take advantage of them. But when he smiles, he knows how to save himself.”

The great actor Şener Şen carefully reads the scenarios that come to him and makes his choice accordingly. His basic idea is to make a concise film. On this subject, his teacher Yavuz Turgul says the following about him:

“One of the best things about Şener is that he wants to shoot a small number of films. Because if he made a large number of films, he would have had the misfortune of repeating himself in an environment that was not vehement about it. When I look at Şener as an actor, I see this – I think they may be wrong, of course… Şener Şen draws an image closer to the east if you separate the east and the west with a line,” says Yavuz Turgul. 

Şener Şen says;
It takes a long time for a name to be learned by the public. The public is interesting, that is, the most ruthless critic. Your name is learned gradually. And then he doesn’t forget.
A good director can create a good actor from even a bad actor, and polish it with editing and short-plan skills. The rest is finance.
Every fan of cinema will taste criticism one day.

 

Silk Road caravans were also carriers of science.

by Prof. Dr. Süleyman Kızıltoprak / Mimar Sinan Fine Arts University

4.09.2021

The caravans that came to Khiva from distant lands did not only do trade, but also carried cultural and civilizational values. They would take copies of the works of the great mathematicians and sciences of Khiva to scholars in other lands.

Khiva is an ancient civilization center established 2,500 years ago in the middle of the Karakum desert. It is at one of the crossroads of the Silk Road, near the Amuderya (Ceyhun) river, south of the Aral Sea. This city has been the apple of the eye of many Turkish states in history. As one of the eastern cities of the Oghuz Turks, it met with Islam since 712.

Khiva, one of the favorite cities of great states such as Ghaznavids, Seljuks and Shaybanids, was almost reborn from its ashes despite being destroyed by Cengizhan in 1220. The city, which has been the capital of the Khiva Khanate since 1598, preserves its ancient historical beauties with its wonderful architectural structures in the heart of Central Asia.

The magnificent city has a silhouette described in fairy tales. The night is different, the day is different. The snow that wraps like a wedding dress on turquoise domes in winter adds a different color to the city. The height of the walls, which shine like gold due to the sun’s rays in the summer, is an average of six meters. The length of the walls, which look like a golden necklace in the middle of the desert, is about 10 kilometers. There are four main gates to enter the city: Main Gate, Stone Gate, Garden Gate and Bukhara Gate. The names of the gates are almost like the gate names of the city walls in Istanbul. It is proof that members of the same civilization, such as Edirne Gate, Topkapi Gate, and Mevlana Gate, have similar feelings and thoughts when naming the place. On the other hand, these namings suggest that Istanbul and Khiva have been sister cities since eternity.

52 Meter height Minaret

When you enter the city from the Main Gate, you feel like you are in a dream. Because as soon as you enter, you encounter the magnificent 52-meter-high minaret of the Cuma Mosque and an extraordinary architectural sight. Cuma Mosque is a work of art with 215 wooden columns decorated with magnificent ceramics.

The Kohne Ark, the Old Palace, has an extraordinary architecture. Especially when you go to the terrace, the whole Hive is in front of your eyes. Wherever you look, you will encounter a magnificent ambiance and beauty. Terraces and minarets like these have always been a center of attraction for those who want to discover the secrets of Khiva. Even though the contemporary tourism explorers of ancient cities stay here for days and months to solve the mysteries of architecture when they arrive in Khiva, they still cannot escape the magic of the city.

Civilization Race

Throughout history, Khiva has been in the race for science and civilization in Bukhara. Khan of Khiva Muhammed Emin Khan attempts to build a minaret higher than the 70-meter-high Kalan Minaret in Bukhara, but once it reaches 29 meters, the project cannot be completed due to lack of budget.

Muhammed Emin Han had a magnificent madrasa built in Khiva in his name. The magnificent tiles on the tower-shaped chimneys of the madrasa display their extraordinary beauty towards the sky with almond and pigeon wing motifs in dark blue and blue. While visiting Khiva, which is famous for its palaces, madrasas and mosques, which is the product of centuries of civilization accumulation, you think that you are traveling in a time tunnel.

Khiva, the center of the Khwarezm region, was a frequent destination for all kinds of trade, as it was one of the important points of the caravans traveling on the Silk Road. It was a center where young male military candidates, who were a source of soldiers for Islamic states during the Middle Ages, gathered. From here, hundreds of young (ghulam) soldiers were sent to Baghdad, Damascus and Cairo every year. Nizamülmülk mentions how important these young people are in terms of military service in his famous work, Siyasetname. They are tall, physically strong and handsome, skilled in archery and unrivaled in horse riding. The caravans that came to Khiva from distant lands did not only do trade, but also carried cultural and civilizational values. They would take copies of the works of the great mathematicians and scientists of Khiva to scholars in other lands.

Historical works written in Khwarezm at XVII-XIX. centuries and at the beginning of the XX. century also provide a lot of information about the commercial relations of the Central Asian Khanates with Russia. In particular, the trade of Khiva and Bukhara caravans to Mangışlak, the adventurous movement of these caravans on the roads, the prevention of Bukhara caravans by Khiva soldiers from time to time, their looting, and the arrival of Russian caravans to Central Asian cities are discussed. The commercial relations that existed in the period after the Kungrad dynasty came to power are also discussed in detail.

High agricultural culture in Khwarezm was formed in ancient times on the basis of artificial irrigation and developed, as in Egypt, Mesopotamia and other countries of the East. This high culture has affected the survival and development of science and civilization values ​​in Khwarezm.

Khwarezm is one of the oldest cultural centers. In these lands, where scientists, poets and mystics made great contributions to the development of science, a national understanding of historiography emerged during the reign of the khans. The works written in this context mostly include the history of the Khiva Khans. However, it provides valuable information about the life and culture of the people of the region, and the economic and political situation of the Khanate. When these works are examined, it is seen that many scientists, historians, poets, painters and musicians grew up in Khwarezm. In Khwarezm, one of the great cultural centers of Central Asia, scholars such as Muhammed Musa al-Khwarizmi, Ebu Abdullah al-Khwarizmi, Abu Reyhan Muhammed al-Biruni grew up and enlightened humanity like a sun with their works.

The foundation of Mathematics was laid

Birûnî, like his predecessor Muhammed ibn Musa al-Khwarizmi, is one of the greatest scientists who founded Uzbek science. It is generally accepted that Harezmi laid the foundations of mathematics in the East, in the Turkish and Islamic world and later in Europe with his works. In this context, the strong influence of Birûnî in the following centuries also affected the development of science in the East.

Khwarezm is the birthplace of many poets and writers. Among the historians of Khwarezm, the works and names of Ebulgazi, Şir Muhammed Mûnis, Muhammed Rıza Agâhî, and Muhammed Yusuf Beyânî came to the fore.

Historians of the Khiva

XVII. Khwarezm historiography of the 19th century begins with the Khiva Khan and the historian Ebulgazi.

The tradition of writing historical works in the Uzbek language was widely continued in the Khiva Khanate, one of the Central Asian Khanates. Famous Uzbek poets and historians Şir Muhammad Mûnis and Muhammed Rıza Agâhî continued the work that Ebulgazi started in the 19th century. These great scholars and historians, in addition to writing the history of Khwarezm, also formed a certain school in this field. Muhammed Yusuf Beyânî, a famous historian and poet who lived in the 19th and early 20th centuries, continued this work. Representatives of this school of historiography not only wrote works on the history of Khwarezm, but also translated many historical works from other Eastern languages ​​into Uzbek.

Khiva is a distinguished city of Uzbekistan, which has values ​​and traditions with its people with the same qualifications. It is an open museum with its ancient architecture. The city, which is surrounded by walls built of earth-colored bricks that turn red when the sun’s rays hit, stands in the middle of the desert with all its nobility like a corner of paradise. The people living in the city are like the people of heaven, who are aware of the values ​​of the places they live in and make great efforts to keep their thousands of years old traditions alive.

When the historical artifacts in Khwarezm are examined, traces of civilization for nearly 3 thousand years are witnessed. Even in mosques and madrasas, motifs and decorations from pre-Christian civilizations can be seen. This situation proves that the Khiva has a close relationship with foreign cultures and civilizations, and that it has an open approach to universal values ​​for thousands of years in terms of science, art and civilization.

Hive, which has deep civilization values ​​in the past and is a center of culture and art today, was chosen as the “Cultural Capital of the Turkish World” in 2020. Programs that could not be done last year due to the effect of the pandemic have started again this year. Tourism programs to be held in Khiva this year are of particular importance.

It’s time to see the Hive.

@suleymankzltprk

Source: https://www.star.com.tr/acik-gorus/ipek-yolu-kervanlari-bilimin-de-tasiyicisiydi-haber-1650523/

Turkish Image in Europe

by Professor Erol Göka

Sociopsychology of European View of Turks [1]

[For Europe, Turks have been seen as “barbarians among us” for centuries. Germans, Normans, and Hungarians also came to Europe as invaders, but eventually integrated. The Arabs also resisted until they were expelled from Europe. The Russians were in a marginal position between assimilation and exclusion. Turks, on the other hand, took place only in their own part of Europe. They neither tried to impose their beliefs nor adopted Christianity. They were admired when they were strong, and hated when they were weak. Pushed from Europe for three hundred years, they could only hold on to its extreme and decided to “Westernize”. It is difficult to find another people who have had such a contradictory and confused relationship with Europe for so long. envy and resentment, Emotions arising from prejudices, such as fascination and fear, complicate the solution of the problem.] (Yerasimos, 2002: Foreword)

In general, it can be said that there is always a skeptical, timid, hesitant and unfriendly view towards “Turk” in Europe. This view is clearly felt in the social and political spheres all over Europe today. This view towards the Turks is actually a part of the general xenophobia in Europe and has been formed in a historical process that embodies the concept of “threatening foreigner”. This fact, ” hermeneutics” (hermeneutics)It falls within the scope of a psychodynamic approach as well as a historical understanding. Although there are racial, religious, economic and social dimensions of Turkish hostility in Europe, it is also necessary to take into account the elements of community psychology, which form the infrastructure of all of them and have a very old foundation.

In order to understand and interpret the psychological elements correctly, first of all, it is necessary to analyze the historical process of the European communities, which have removed the word “Europe” from being a word that defines only a geographical area, and the historical adventures of European communities, which have been able to meet on a common ground despite many differences among themselves.

Turkish: The “Other” That Europe is Using to Define Itself!

The origins of Europe’s encounter with and hostile attitude towards foreigners can be traced back to the 4th century AD. During the mass migrations that started in the 4th century and lasted until the 13th century and greatly affected Europe, the concept of “nation” did not exist in Europe yet, and the concept of foreigner was used to describe communities living outside the domain of Greek or Roman sovereignty in this period. With the beginning of the migration of tribes in 375, the Huns captured a significant part of Northern Europe and the European experienced the first concern of survival in the face of this threat. It was during this period that the European started to use the word “barbarian”, which is a phonetic equivalent of the “dark, aggressive human figure whose language he does not understand”, which comes to life in his imagination when the word “foreigner” is mentioned (Erdheim, 1984).

In the conditions of this period, Factors such as race, ethnicity and religion are not yet decisive in the acceptance of the Turk as a foreigner and the hostile attitude towards the Turk. During the migration of the Huns, Europe was the scene of many wars and massacres for about a hundred years, and “the very sight of them scares people, they can ride a horse very well, use weapons, are extremely brutal and aggressive” (Dollinger, 1999). caused fear and hostility to take root. It caused an indelible fear and hostility to take root in the minds of Europeans for centuries. It caused an indelible fear and hostility to take root in the minds of Europeans for centuries.

This article aims to examine how the European identity is formed by mediating the Turkish image. We include historical information only for this purpose. In order to understand the abstract conflict that has taken place between the “foreigner from afar”, that is, the “other” since their encounter with the Huns, the mentality of the Europeans must also be examined with the methods of group psychology, which we have discussed in this book. The theme of the “other” has so far occupied an extensive place in philosophy and sociology; whereas the subject is basically within the domain of psychology. For this reason, we would like to focus on how a psychological perspective can be useful for us in examining the formation and behavior of large group identity, and in addressing the problem of the “other”, by using the European encounter with the Turks as a means.

Redefineding International Relations in The Light of Psychology

In recent international relations publications, it has been suggested that the realistic approach, which argues that political decision is rational, makes macro-level analysis, and asserts that the main actor is the state, is out of date, and instead it is suggested that macro-level analysis and micro-level analyzes should be combined, events are multidimensional and cyclical, not just cause-effects. An approach has been proposed, which advocates understanding with the processes that are thought to be present and focusing on an interdisciplinary approach (Hudson, Vore, 2002). While there is an evolution in this direction in the discipline of international relations, micro-level, individual and “intrapsychic” (inside psychology) such as psychology and psychoanalysis. Studies investigating ethnic groups and nations, group-leader relations based on group processes have also increased in disciplines examining processes, and the knowledge in this field has begun to be used in the resolution of conflicts between large groups.

For example, the theories emerging from social psychology, in relation to international conflicts, against the arguments of the realist approach, “mutuality” in international relations. He brought propositions emphasizing the importance of human and human factor. According to them, international relations and especially conflicts are the result of the functioning of some psycho-social processes arising from the collective needs or fears of the communities, rather than a rational decision that emerges as a result of an objective evaluation.

Conflict in international relations is a phenomenon that operates in inter-communal processes rather than conflicts between states. International conflict does not arise because of the great harm caused by one side using force over the other, it consists of an alternating process between the two sides that has multiple phases and is shaped by mutual interaction. In addition, international conflicts are not a series of behaviors in which actors mutually influence and react to each other, but are self-replicating, provocative, it follows an interactive course with a multiplier dynamic (Kelman, Fisher, 2003).

From this point of view, it is possible to argue that psychology and psychoanalysis can be used, among other disciplines, to understand international conflicts that are seen to be effective at the international level (Volkan, 2005). Psychological and psychoanalytic analysis by avoiding psychological reductionism is thought to contribute greatly to understanding the conflicts that arise between large groups such as nations and ethnic groups (Göral, 2005).

Large group identity is the identity of the individuals who make up a group, internalized in the growth and socialization processes and intertwined with their personal identities, the existence and effects of which are not known when faced with a significant threat, but which are in fact as decisive as individual identity of “mental representations” that determineIt consists of a set of codes. In his “tent model”, Volkan (1995: p.40) envisions the large-group identity with an image on the clothing representing the individual identity of the person, with a tent cloth covering all the members of that group, and with the leader as the pole of the tent. This tent cloth actually brings individuals together under the “sense of we-ness”, creates a border between the outside and the inside of the tent, and protects the group against the threat from outside. However, if there is a tear in the canvas or a jolt in the pole, the group’s sense of we-ness increases and individuals perceive more clearly that they are living under a tent. Even in these situations of danger, large-group identity becomes more important than the personal identity of individuals.

In our opinion, Volkan’s understanding of the tent model is quite easy to understand and useful, but it does not shed sufficient light on the psychologically impulsive origins. In order to examine the psychology of the formation of a large group’s identity in more detail, the concept of “projective identification “, which we have included in the article “Projective Identity as a tool for comprehending human relations” in this book and which we have discussed with our friends elsewhere (Göka et al., 2004), is very useful. seems useful. Let us briefly recall the concept of projective identification.

“Object relations” in post-Freudian psychoanalysisMelanie Klein (1946), known as the founder of the theory, observed the effects of the infant’s experiences in her relationship with her mother, to the great existential anxiety created by her fragmented perceptual world, and formed a theory from the conceptualizations she came up with. Projective identification is one of the basic elements of this theory. Many perspectives on projective identification have been developed after Klein, and today the concept has risen to the level of one of the key concepts in understanding human relations, with more detailed observations, going far beyond the way it was first put forward, and enriched with other perspectives such as communication theory. The area defined by projective identification, It includes almost all human relations and covers the dynamics and communication types in early childhood of what we give and receive in relation to the other person and how we make this exchange.

Today, we can easily accept that projective identifications inevitably take place in our relationships, as we bring them with our human being, that is, they arise directly from our being human. Projective identification of being human, socialization, “self” (egoA well-understood understanding of the place of ) in the development processes and forms of relationship will contribute to the understanding of the nature of psychopathologies (mental disorders), psychotherapeutic (for the purpose of mental treatment) relationship and psychotherapy process, as well as many problems in human relations. Moreover, thanks to the efforts of other theorists who developed Klein’s view, projective identification will become indispensable in the development of the identities of large groups (community, community, institution, nation) and in understanding the relations they establish with each other.

According to Melani Klein’s first psychoanalytic conceptualization, projective identification is one of the defense mechanisms that human infants develop in order to cope with the difficulties they experience in the first months of their lives. The infant projects negative mental representations that are not yet integrated in order to survive and survive the destructive influence of the aggressive instinct inside. He lives them as if they are coming from outside. Man reflects the evil within himself to the outside by projection; He tries to get rid of it with the illusion that “I am not the bad one, he is”. It identifies the other person with the bad material it reflects. He begins to treat her as if she is suitable for the material he reflects, thus forcing him to accept this identity that he reflects, and often making him accept it. The reflections coming from the baby also play a major role in this behavior of the mother, who, feeling guilty, is eager to feed her baby as soon as possible.

The reason why post-Klein theorists argue that projective identification is valid in all kinds of human relations and in the identity formation of large groups and their relations with each other, based on this theory, is that they see the origins of our effort to get rid of the burden of negativities within ourselves and to impose them on the other person in order to create a purer identity for ourselves. . Humans and human groups always use this mechanism to which the human infant resorts. Indeed, projective identification plays an important role in the formation and development of nations as a large group. Establishing a sense of we-nessIn order to be one fist and gather around idealized features, the society must reflect the evil inside and create an enemy/evil outside.

If we go back to the mood of the European who came face to face with the Huns, which is our main subject: Based on the theory of projective identification, it can be said that Europe, which was incapable of ensuring its unity and agitated by the civil wars of the pagan tribes, for the long time leading up to the establishment of the Roman Empire, only struggled to survive in this process and kept the xenophobia that developed in parallel with this in community psychology.

While the Roman Empire politically brought the peoples of Europe together, it attained the core elements of a more institutional identity with which it would define itself together with European consciousness (and unconsciousness), Roman Law and Christianity. In the early periods of the Roman Empire, as mentioned earlier, the identities of those living within the empire’s borders were determined by ethnicity, race, and not defined by differences in religion. As Christianity became more and more the most important unifying factor, the definition of foreigner came to mean those who held both extra-imperial and non-Christian beliefs.

Later, with the Renaissance, adding Greek humanism and aesthetics to the unifying elements of Roman Law and Christianity, Europe had the chance to define its identity in a historical process. However, there is one more thing missing for the establishment of an identity, which is where to put the negativities in it, especially the elements related to violence and aggression. The solution to this problem of the European identity will come from the Hun attacks. Thanks to the Huns, who threatened its existence, the European established the “other” of his identity as Turks. In the same period, the victories of the Muslim Arabs against Europe also contribute to the formation of the European identity (Göka, 1999).

Thus, the image of “Muslim” was added to the image of “bad Turk” that started with the Huns, but with the Arab victories, the Turks began to push the gates of Europe again, this time as the leader and standard-bearer of Islam, so that the “Muslim” was no longer needed for the European and made the Muslim identical (Balivet, 2005: p.15).

European identity has now consolidated its “other” during the Crusades and Ottoman expansion. The Turkish image, which constitutes the “other” of the European identity throughout the process until today, will complete its existence for the European, reflect and convey all kinds of unsettling features in itself, It will serve as a psychological reservoir to which In order to create his own identity, the European will pour all the negative qualities in himself onto the Turkish image, clear himself of negativities, and perceive the Turkish reality by mixing it with this negative material that he reflects.

We have now reached the negotiation stage in the process of accession to the European Union. Obviously, the diplomatic language and international relations discourses do not allow the socio-psychological dimensions of the process to be sufficiently revealed. But this dimension is too important to be neglected. We tried to analyze what happened on the Turkish side in this process before (Göka, 2004). Now, in this article, as an introduction, we will focus on the Turkish image in Europe, which is the basis for Europeans to perceive Turks today. Let us consider the historical process in a little more detail this time.

New Thousand Years, Old “Other ”

The Europe of the new millennium is a continent where the majority of the people are extremely poor, live in very difficult conditions and face the danger of starvation. Resources are extremely limited and the productive class, exploited by landowners and warriors, is also spiritually exploited by priests (Huberman, 2000). In this period when people feel weak against the forces of nature and it is believed that God’s anger can cause various disasters, the church has an absolute importance in obtaining God’s approval. The church establishment uses it; it has great power and influence on people (Subaşı, 2002). As seen by the 1000s AD, there are extremely collective fears in Europe that hold the continent’s communities together; hunger, Besides disease and war, all kinds of strangers are also feared (Delumeau, 1985).

The behavior that has traditionally existed in Europe since the ancient empires, to devalue and humiliate all kinds of foreigners, to attribute to them being dangerous as well as all kinds of negative qualities, was shaped as a reflection of negative features such as sinfulness, ugliness and evil against their neighbors living on the same continent during this period. . People perceive the starting point of the borders of their own small country as the starting point of the “foreigner” and expect all kinds of threats and evil from those beyond these borders. Even among villagers and urban residents living in the same region, there are similar feelings of insecurity (Subaşı, 2002). When the superstitions of this period are examined, It can easily be seen that it is shaped according to such attitudes.

A stranger should look at the milk bucket with the belief that it will spoil the fertility, be in the same environment while milking or making butter, enter the kitchen or the barn, eat the crust, which is the most useful part of the bread, without meeting certain conditions (give the baby blessed water and say “God bless you”) it is strictly forbidden to touch it (see German Dictionary of Superstitions”). Moreover, foreigners are considered to be the harbingers of the plague and war, which was very feared at that time.

The foreigners mentioned here are the “local” foreigners who live side by side on the same continent, on the same land, and are neighbors of Europeans, and it can be said that these foreigners cannot have the same effect on the European as the Turks did. In addition to these, social fears fueled by the belief in the end of the world in the millennium and increasing the influence of the church on people also accelerate the situation. With the belief that the “enemy of Christianity” will emerge and that terrible peoples from far corners of the world will attack Europe, in line with what is written in the Bible, Europe has begun to wait for the arrival of its new fear (Glaser, 1999). The new foreign, non-Christian, remote, whose fear and hostility are defined, probably the attacker coming from the East is a foreigner (Subaşı, 2002).

For such reasons, Turks come first in the concept of “all kinds of foreigners” and the psychodynamic mechanism that Europeans will use against foreigners is shaped as projective identification. According to this; It is the Turks who suffer the most from the reflection of all kinds of negative features such as sinfulness, ugliness and evil; Because the Turks, who came from the steppes of Central Asia and started to spread from Anatolia to the West, were very different from both Arab, Iranian, Kurdish co-religionists and Christian communities. “Oddly enough, the Turk, who appears everywhere, is in many respects described in a very similar way by both Christian and Muslim sources. It is as if the ‘exoticism’ of the Turk is as clear as daylight for both Arab and Iranian allies and hostile Christians… One point that everyone unquestionably accepts is the value of the Turk as a warrior” (Balivet, 2005: p.19). There are many known accounts of medieval historians about these warrior qualities of the communities that first encountered the Turks.

Although the tolerant and just administration of the Turks in their powerful, hierarchical state causes admiration such as “Turkish oppression is a child rather than Arab justice” or “I prefer a Turk’s turban to a Latin headdress”, the main thing is hatred and fear from them.“When Turks refuse to give up their strong cultural differences and identities, which do not fully coincide with strict Muslim behavior, disagreements, misunderstandings and suspicions arise on the side of their coreligionists.

Moreover, it leads to a rift with the former Arab-Muslim powers of the Mediterranean, with Christians who have been accustomed for centuries to maintain a certain status quo, but who are not familiar with the customs of the steppe peoples. At that time, severe criticism and contemptuous exclusion that formed the negative Turkish image and that black portrait that would last throughout the Middle Ages and much later begins… A strong sense of identity, customs that bear the strong stamp of nomadism, war and Central Asian shamanism, distinguish Turkish peoples from time immemorial. are their distinctive qualities… These customs are; It continues after Islamization and is against Muslims who strictly adhere to the orders of religion; It does not bother the Turks, who, in addition to their Muslim names, retain their special nicknames that literally represent shamanic totems… Even though foreigners are startled by the peculiar customs and body language of the Turks, they have to obey them in order to make an alliance or a truce with them.”(Balivet, 2005:pp.25-27).

The languages of the Turks are strange, their physical appearance is foreign, their clothes and customs are strange.“Christian and Muslim sources are united in vilifying the identities of the Turks, which, depending on the situation, are found to be startling, even disgusting, and almost always threatening or frankly frightening… When speaking of Turks, ‘unconscious Turks’ (etrak-ı bi-idrak), ‘dirty Turks’ Greek, Armenian, Latin or Syriac writers join Arab and Persian writers who use derogatory terms such as (etrak-ı na-pak) with similar insults. Some speak of the Turkish ‘oppression’ and the ‘violence’ of the steppe peoples, others describe the Turks as ‘the devil’s people’, ‘bloodthirsty wild beasts’; while others emphasize the ‘barbarism of their way of life’… The greed, ruthlessness, sold-out, disloyalty, etc. of the Turk, who raids only to gain loot and material wealth, etc. often emphasized(Balivet, 2005: pp.31-34, p.58). Yes, an “other” has been found again, to which the European can pour all his evils for the construction of identity.

When it comes to Europe of the Middle Ages, with the definition of the concept of the foreigner, the view of the foreigner has also undergone a transformation. Due to the importance of the notion of religion with the stronger “other”, the feared foreigner in Medieval Europe is this time “non-Christian”.

Among these, it is Muslims who threaten Europe’s material and spiritual existence the most, and although the fear of Muslims was against the whole understanding represented by the Arab tribe, as it was mentioned before, the real fear of Muslims is literally “Eastern”, which Europe recognizes in the migration of tribes.

It was embodied by the threat of “Muslim Turks” along with the figure of the “aggressive man coming from By reusing the European primitive psychic mechanisms, he identified the distant foreigner as the scapegoat for his inability to establish his own internal integrity, and with the Seljuk Turks’ capture of Jerusalem in 1076, He was able to establish the first unity and alliance in his history against the “other” he defined as “Muslim Turk”.

Thus, in the 12th and 13th centuries, Europe established the unity it had never been able to establish in its history in the form of the “Christian European People” against the “Muslim other” – that is, the Turks – and the new projective identification process that started on this occasion lasted from 1147 to 1270. During the 6th Crusade, which was the first time, the barbarian was the greatest comforter of the Europeans in legitimizing all kinds of atrocities against foreigners.

In addition, Europe has hardened its attitude towards non-believers within itself, and has started to slaughter Jews in the continent in addition to the Crusades it has been carrying out against foreigners (Subaşı, 2002).In the 12th and 13th centuries, the new projective identification process that started with the “Christian European People” against the “Muslim other” – that is, the Turks – that it could never establish until that time in its history, and the 6 Crusaders that lasted from 1147 to 1270.

Throughout his expedition, he was the European’s greatest comforter in legitimizing all his atrocities against the barbarian foreigner. In addition, Europe has hardened its attitude towards non-believers within itself, and has started to slaughter Jews in the continent, in addition to the Crusades it has been carrying out against foreigners (Subaşı, 2002).During the 6 Crusades that lasted from 1147 to 1270, the barbarian was the European’s greatest comforter in legitimizing all his atrocities against the foreigner. In addition, Europe has hardened its attitude towards non-believers within itself, and has started to slaughter Jews in the continent in addition to the Crusades it has been carrying out against foreigners (Subaşı, 2002).

Social classes that became evident in the 19th century with the migration of exploited peasants from the countryside and the emergence of craftsmanship as a new source of income; new occupational groups such as artisans, craftsmen and merchants began to emerge. With the establishment of towns and urbanization in parallel with these developments, Jews began to operate predominantly in the listed occupational groups (Pirenne, 2002).

The Jews, who started to increase their influence in social life, were targeted by the Church as enemies of religion and those who sucked the blood of the people; they were forced to change their religion, to be baptized, and a large number of Jews who did not accept these were either massacred or forced to commit suicide (Subaşı, 2002). In this period, against the Jews who were excluded from social life in the 12th century and started to live in the ghettos of the cities.

The definition of “inner foreigner” in Europe took the form of a definite exclusion from social life, with the introduction of strict rules such as wearing signs indicating that they were Jewish on their clothes. It can be said that the prototypes of the systematic, organized and institutional coercion and oppression applied against the foreigner in Europe in the Nazi era were already visualized long ago, 8 centuries ago. Europe, not content with such exclusion, blamed the Jews for the social disasters and punished the Jews by burning them or expelling them from their countries, on the grounds that they caused the great plague epidemic that took place in the 14th century (Fried, 1999). The fact that he reflects bad qualities by putting himself in a bad mood has further developed his insecurity.

Centuries of Accumulation: Foreigners That Need To Be Exterminated

By the turn of the century, Christianity was now literally the sole and common unifying element of European societies, above all differences. The Church, with the help of historical enmity accumulation, shows Judaism and Islam as the biggest threat in this period. According to the Church, these foreigners who are “anti-Christians”, whether they come from within or outside of society, must be destroyed or converted before the Empire of God can be established. For these reasons, not only Jews and Muslims, but also scientists with discoveries other than Christian teachings or countless women accused of witchcraft were massacred and targeted by the Church or the public (Subaşı, 2002).

The 15th and 17th centuries were the periods when Europe saw the Muslim Turks as the greatest threat. Beginning with the Ottoman advance in the Balkans in the 15th century, Europe’s concerns for survival in the face of this “aggressive foreigner from the East” re-emerged. Modern Europe will perceive the Ottomans in the same way as the West perceived the Turk in the Middle Ages: the dangerous enemy to be feared and to be eliminated, to be feared. However, behind this fear and hostility, there is often a certain admiration.

The following words of the Austrian ambassador in Istanbul in 1560 reveal everything clearly:“When I compare the Turkish system with ours, I shudder to think about the future… On the Turks’ side are the resources of a mighty empire, the experience and training of war, experienced soldiers, familiarity with victory, frugality and prudence. On our side, there is general poverty, personal wealth, powerlessness, impaired faith, lack of tolerance and education. Our soldiers are disobedient, our officers are greedy, they do not care about discipline; dishonesty, recklessness and immorality are knee-deep… Since nobility, offices and ministries are the rewards of talent and virtue among the Turks, deceitful, lazy and sluggish never rise; They are respected and despised: these are the reasons why the Turks succeed in whatever they do, become the superior race, and expand their reign day by day. Our methods are very different. We do not attach any importance to virtues. It all depends on soy. This is the only way to reach high positions. I could talk more about this elsewhere. You should not share what I have said with anyone, you should keep it to yourself.”(Busbecq, 2002: pp.61-62; pp.103-104).

With the conquest of Constantinople in 1453, Europe fell into a complete depression, and the economic and cultural systems that sustained it were faced with the threat of collapse. Indeed, the conquest of Constantinople, the capture of the metropolis is a theme that will never be erased from the identity-forming memory of the West. After Iznik, Antakya and Jerusalem, the conquest of Constantinople by the Muslims is the greatest trauma for the Western consciousness (and unconscious). People lament after this trauma and rituals are held in churches. The theme of the fall of the metropolises as a literary or religious inspiration, a subject of political thought or a sign of apocalypse was especially engraved in the memories of the Middle Ages. As contemporary reflections of this intellectual field about identity, The Greek-Orthodox megali idea, which focuses on the retake of Constantinople, or the Israeli-Arab conflict over the ownership of Jerusalem can be cited as an example (Balivet, 2005: p.88).

One of the important roles of the Turks’ capture of Constantinople in the construction of the European identity is that they were thought of as Trojans and that Mehmet the Conqueror said, “In the past, Greeks, Macedonians, Thessalians, Peloponnesians destroyed these places, after all this time they were often unfairly treated. and I avenged the Asians they persecuted by punishing their grandchildren”. After the conquest of Constantinople, the European consciousness will compare the Turks with the Romans, and the belief that these warlike, contented people who take care of their subjects can establish a universal monarchy will settle in the unconscious of the people, starting with the observations of the travelers (Yerasimos, 2002: p.23).

In the 16th and 16th centuries, both the migration of European peasants to the lands under the rule of Turks, who had a more just and soft administration understanding, and the conversion of thousands of Europeans to Islam, the European view of Turks became more hostile and it was a material and moral threat, It has caused him to see himself as an aggressor who needs to be united against. Realizing the brutal and exploitative aspects of its own feudal order, Europe found the solution by reflecting these to the other side and tried to achieve its cohesion in this period with this reflection. In addition to all these, some geographers, historians, travelers and diplomats emphasized the positive aspects of the Ottoman Empire in their works on the Ottoman Empire, It deepened the fear of the Church, which felt responsible for ensuring the integrity of Europe, and forced it to take new steps.

In the face of this great and serious threat that it could not cope with, the Church invited all Christians to pray to God every day to ask for help against the Ottomans, and even to ring the Turkish bells at certain times of the day in some parts of Europe to remind the danger and keep people constantly on alert. implemented the application. While all this is being done, Europe is unanimous that the Turk is a threat, but beyond that, European dignitaries have a more important concern: how the European people recognize the Turk… Because now the “aggressive man from the East” is destroying the existence of Europe. threatens both the substance and the mana platform. Then reflection will come into play again. After the Mohac War, the Ottoman sultan had 2000 cut heads erected in front of his tent as a sign of victory.

Integration against a common enemy has been tried to be achieved by creating a common concern (Delumeau, 1985; Dollinger, 1999).Integration against a common enemy has been tried to be achieved by creating a common concern (Delumeau, 1985; Dollinger, 1999).Integration against a common enemy has been tried to be achieved by creating a common concern (Delumeau, 1985; Dollinger, 1999).

This great fear of Turks in Europe; it is a fear that has been processed by the church elders and inflated with various methods and for certain purposes (Subaşı, 2002). This mechanism shows that the “other” called “Turk” played the main role in ensuring the unity of Europe in the Middle Ages. This “unity against the dangerous other” behavior was effective even in the 16th century, when sectarian quarrels began to take place in Europe. Sultan Suleiman’s First Siege of Vienna failed and during the stagnation period of the Ottoman Empire, Europe started to make progress in the technical and cultural field, but the “Muslim Turk” remained indifferent to these advances that would shape the world civilization. The defeat of the Second Siege of Vienna in 1683, in the memory of the European.

It has a place as the salvation of Christianity and all European culture.  In the period between the end of the 16th century and the beginning of the 18th century, this role given to the Turks came to an end, the faults of the Turks were examined rather than their virtues, and their Eastern customs were criticized. From the Turkish type, which was admired as much as feared, to the Turkish type, which was hated as much as it was despised. It is clear that this change is a result of the decline of the Ottoman Empire and the rise of Europe (Yerasimos, 2002: p.30).It is clear that this change is a result of the decline of the Ottoman Empire and the rise of Europe (Yerasimos, 2002: p.30).It is clear that this change is a result of the decline of the Ottoman Empire and the rise of Europe (Yerasimos, 2002: p.30).

Another important development that emerged in Europe in the 19th century is the emergence of the concept of “nation”. The Ottoman Empire, on the other hand, started to weaken in the same period; The Turkish image was identified with the “sick man” in the eyes of the Westerners, and it began to be perceived as a foreign object that caused severe national crises due to its weakness in Europe. It was realized at that time that there would not be a single European empire in the era of nation-states, and that many nation-states would emerge, and a structuring accordingly began. With nationalism, which is the official ideology of the nation-states age, nations have competed with each other, even sectarian wars have become power struggles and moves to come of age.

Europe, which sought the “other” after the advance of the “aggressive man from the east” stopped, this time, it went into divisions within itself, and after each division, it produced new foreigners for itself and started to reflect on these foreigners that it had created within itself for centuries. After the 1650s, that is, after the emergence of the social structures that laid the foundation for the establishment of nation-states, new definitions of foreigners were made with the social and political conditions of the period (Schöneberg, 1987; Wagner, Zick, 1993). “Stranger” is now defined from the perspective of ethnocentrism. Undoubtedly, within this definition, Turks are still foreigners, but due to their lack of threatening power, Turks were seen as a “neutralized enemy” at that time.

The economic infrastructure of the nation-state age is industrial capitalism. The machinery of capitalism operating in the infrastructure in Europe will plunge the society into sharp class conflicts in the form of bourgeois and proletariat. In this period, reflection came into play again, the feelings of hatred and enmity between the classes within the country were again reflected on the “foreigner”, and this defense mechanism, this time, served the functioning of capitalism and paved the way for the outbreak of two world wars (Claussen, 1994). Indeed, it is possible to find the hatred and enmity projected on the Turks in all of the Enlightenment thinkers in this period, and this is very sad.“Thus, the image of the Turk in the minds of the West has turned into a harmful entity that should no longer live.  From now on, the era in which the Turks are models will come to an end and the West will believe in its own universality. Pascal writes, ‘How painful it is to meet so many unbelieving and infidel Turks who practice what they saw from their ancestors’” (Yerasimos, 2002: p.32). Anti-Turkish sentences emerge from the pen of Diderot, Montesquieu, Voltaire, Chateaubriand and Hugo; In this period, the Turk turns into a scapegoat, on which the sins of the West are burdened and must be sent to the depths of Asia.

The ideals of the Enlightenment period, which started in the 18th century in Europe and added a new dimension to the return to Greek humanism in the Renaissance and Reformation Movements, and the concepts of freedom, equality, fraternity, science and technology, which came to the fore with the French Revolution, are the new symbols of modernity and Europe.  European-origin modernity creates an aura of attraction all over the world and spreads rapidly. However, this aura of attraction is also combined with hostile feelings towards Europe, which is trying to spread modernity through colonial methods. European-origin modernity could not bring peace, freedom and brotherhood to the world, on the contrary, it increased tensions and conflicts and caused two great wars to break out around the world.

Therefore, modernity, which affects the whole world, does not have a positive effect on the functioning of European consciousness. The power gained from the developments in science and technology has led to the invasion of a scientistic, positivist ideology in the minds of the European people and racist theories that see the rest of the world as primitive-savages. With this theory, white Europeans are declared the highest of creations, and the European lifestyle and civilization are accepted as the pinnacle of human history. Along with these acceptances, new definitions of foreigners emerged: non-white Europeans; those who are behind or below Europeans in terms of culture and civilization, intellectual abilities and even spiritual values; that is, the rest of the world’s people. The position of the European against these foreigners; congenital, biological and genetic, depending on its natural superiority, it is the authoritative, “master” position that knows “right” to dominate and exploit secretly and openly.

While it is claimed that whites take on the role of “missionary” against other races that are “less civilized”, in fact, the economic goals of colonialism are educational, religious, etc. It was tried to be covered with the understanding of “mission” (Egger, 1994). Turks are also one of the races that oppose all kinds of progress, are psychologically inferior and will never be able to get rid of this quality. European anthropology sees Turks as a primitive people, devoid of all kinds of pleasure, indifferent to all kinds of arts, lazy, insensitive, incapable of doing anything, and indulging in the most disgusting pleasures, and Turkish as a primitive language (Yerasimos, 2002: pp.41-42) .1994). Turks are also one of the races that oppose all kinds of progress, are psychologically inferior and will never be able to get rid of this quality. European anthropology sees Turks as a primitive people, devoid of all kinds of pleasure, indifferent to all kinds of arts, lazy, apathetic, incapable of doing anything, and indulging in the most disgusting pleasures, and Turkish as a primitive language (Yerasimos, 2002: pp.41-42) .1994). Turks are also one of the races that oppose all kinds of progress, are psychologically inferior and will never be able to get rid of this quality.

European anthropology sees Turks as a primitive people, devoid of all kinds of pleasure, indifferent to all kinds of arts, lazy, apathetic, incapable of doing anything, and indulging in the most disgusting pleasures, and Turkish as a primitive language (Yerasimos, 2002: pp.41-42) .“The primitive Turk will always remain at the level of an animal. He is a civilized savage. If you scrape off the outer polish, you’ll find the Tatar underneath. Education cannot quench his wilderness.” “The Turkish empire is worse than reactionary and is a phenomenon against history. It has always been and always will be a land of war.

Turks are real Huns who are descended from Genghis Khan, Tamerlane and Atilla. Their lifestyle is always militaristic, so they can never look at the world differently. Their dominance is based on slavery, concubinage in their homes and harems, on the enslavement of non-Turkish non-Muslim races. They maintain their dominance through wars and massacres.” “Turks are indeed very low on the intelligence level chart… History has shown us that Turks do not have the capacity for intelligence. That’s why they can’t rule the country. How can qualified peoples like Indians and Egyptians listen to the advice of the uncivilized Turk? A Turk cannot be a leader, he is completely incompetent and his mental faculties are not developed. (cited by Yerasimos, 2002: pp.43-44).

With this definition of foreigner, another legitimation has been made and this legitimation effort has saved Europe from the conflict of contradictions with the values it has produced, a new conflict of values and interests, by reflecting some inferior qualities to the “other”. Racism, which flourished on this very fertile ground, and defining the foreigner in an ethnocentric way became an integral part of the European view and hostility towards foreigners since the 19th century, and this situation has now reached its zenith in the 20th century.

The European, who looks at the Turkish with the turn of the century, is happy to see that the reflections he has made for centuries work. The Ottoman Empire, which was disintegrated after suffering a heavy defeat in the First World War, brought the Christian elements to join Europe and the European consciousness, on the one hand, and on the other hand, it led to the revival of the image of the “cruel Turk”. The Turks, who fell in love with re-establishing a modern republic from the ashes of the empire, evoked mixed feelings in the European consciousness. They are still standing, and this greatly angers the European consciousness:“The European mentality draws conclusions from data by observing and examining objects in their own environment.

But what to do when it comes to a special race like the Turks and a special country like Turkey? Is it possible to talk about a homogeneous nation with a language, history, customs and traditions that come from the same root, in short, whose homeland is Turkey? Never, never has it been, and never will be.”(as cited in Yerasimos, 2002: p.40). However, the fact that the Turks adopt modernization as an ideal, and especially that some of them call the modernization process “Westernization”, pleases the Europeans and satisfies the European egos.

The fact that European scientists are so eager to do research on Turkish modernization and that these studies attract great attention is because the inferior qualities reflected in the reflection process are accepted by the reflector and their internalization shows that the reflector achieves his goal. However, this situation did not change Europe’s perception of Turks as foreigners and threats. The Turk, who entered Europe with force, coercion and threat yesterday, has started to enter this geography this time with the invitation of Europe itself; Europe is now the “door to the hand in need”. Along with the Turks who went to Europe as workers in the 1960s, Europe perceived the Turk as a different threat this time and fell into the idea that he had entered into its body as a Trojan horse that carried the accumulation of centuries. This time, the concept of “foreigner outside” has left its place to a concept of “foreign inside”, which has been redefined especially for Turks, due to the large number of immigrants from Turkey in this period.

This period’s conceptualization of the inside brought along the risk of destroying the culture of the Europeans and the civilization they had built over the centuries. After the Second Vienna Defeat, the hostility against the Turks eased, and it flared up again as the Turks entered Europe, this time in a different way. Turks, who became the target of neo-Nazi movements in Germany, especially in the 90s,have been subjected to deliberate exclusion culturally and politically. Again, the European chose the way of relaxation by reflecting his own brutality and phobias on Turks without any difficulty, with a habit from history.

Meanwhile, with the collapse of the bipolar world in the same period, the balance established between the capitalist and socialist camp has been disrupted, and a new need for the “other” has emerged for the entire West. September 11, 2001 is a milestone declaring this new “other”; It is now clear that the new “other” is “Islamic terrorism”. When we look at our subject from the perspective of Europe, we see that the discourse of Islamic terrorism reinforces the already negative Turkish image in Europe. The foreign enemy within Europe, It is not only Turks but all Muslims, but historical memory and the European Union process that has been underway for a while brings the Turks to the fore again. For the European, the sure way to get rid of the Turks cannot be found.

Turks who want to join the European Union are nothing but the growing danger of the “foreign inside” in the eyes of the European who has such a historical background about themselves. Even in these difficult situations, the Turks once again left Europe with a stalemate. The projective identification mechanism that the European has operated throughout its history has become useless because of the Turks’ attitudes that do not care at all about the material projected to them and follow their own way.

The European consciousness is concerned about not finding a new solution for itself. With the Turks’ demand to enter the European Union coming to their doorstep, they do not know what to do in the face of this situation where the old mechanisms do not work, but on the other hand, the traces of the old hostility and fears cannot be erased. If he throws the Turks into himself, he has to vomit his old projections and project his own negative sides to someone else (for example, the USA). If it fails to achieve a new process of reflection and self-locking, the result is utterly disastrous.

Again, a Europe facing the threat of its own integrity, and the former scapegoat Turks as the reason for this… The stage today is no longer the battlefields, but the negotiation tables.

[1] This article, originally published with the title “From the battlefields to the negotiation tables: The Turkish image in Europe” (with Dr. M. Beyazyüz, with Dr. FV Yüksel- Türkiye Diary, Fall 2005, 82: 5-18.) was later published. Then it was rearranged and included in the 2006 edition of the book “Human Part, Part” published by Aşina Kitaplar. It was removed from the book with the arrangement made during the publication of the book by Vadi Publishing in 2019. The text you are reading is from 2006.

Source: http://www.erolgoka.net/avrupada-turk-imgesi/

RESOURCES

Alman Batıl İnançları Sözlüğü. Handwörterbuch des Deutschen Aberglaubens. (1984). Berlin und Leipzig (1928), zit. in: Fremd ist der, der heute kommt und morgen bleibt“, Integration, Bayaz A, Damolin M, Ernst H (Hrsg), Beltz Verlag, Weinheim und Basel. (Aktaran Subaşı,  2002).

Balivet M. (2005). Ortaçağda Türkler.   Güntekin E. çeviren.  İstanbul, Alkım Yayınları.

Busbecq O. G. (2002). Türk Mektupları.  Özkan H. çeviren. İstanbul, Ark Kitapları.

Claussen D.(1994). Was heißt Rassismus?, Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, Darmstadt. (Aktaran Subaşı,  2002).

Delumeau J. (1985). Angst im Abendland – Die Geschichte kollektiver Ängste im Europa des 14.-18. Jhdt’s. Reinbek, Hamburg. (Aktaran Subaşı,  2002).

Dollinger H. (1999). Schwarzbuch der Weltgeschichte. 5000 Jahre der Mensch des Menschen Feind. Komet, Frechen. (Aktaran Subaşı,  2002).

Egger A. (1994). Rassismus und Ethnozentrismus- Beobachtungen und Reflektionen. In: Fuchs G, Schratz M (Hrsg): Interkulturelles Zusammenleben- aber wie?, Österreichischer Studien Verlag, Innsbruck. (Aktaran Subaşı,  2002).

Erdheim M. (1984). Fremd ist der, der heute kommt und morgen bleibt. In: Bayaz A, Damolin M, Ernst H (Hrsg), Integration-Anpassung an die Deutschen?, Beltz Verlag, Weinheim. (Aktaran Subaşı,  2002).

Fried J. (1999). Endzeiterwartung und Fortschritt. In: Tausend Jahre Abendland-Die grossen Umbrüche. Suhrkamp Verlag, Frankfurt am Main. (Aktaran Subaşı,  2002).

Glaser H. (1999). 1000-Europa erwacht. In: Tausend Jahre Abendland-Die grossen Umbrüche. Suhrkamp Verlag, Frankfurt am Main. (Aktaran Subaşı,  2002).

Göka E. (1999). Helsinki’den sonra Avrupa’yı düşünmek. Avrasya Dosyası  5:4: 248-266.

Göka E. (2004). Avrupa Avrupa duy sesimizi: AB karşısında Türkiye’nin kültürel ve psikolojik konumu. Euro Agenda Avrupa Günlüğü  3:5: 231-249.

Göka E., Göral S., F.V. Yüksel. (2004). Birbirimize ne yapıyoruz? İnsan ilişkilerini kavramanın bir aracı olarak yansıtmalı özdeşim. Avrasya Dosyası  10:1:279-315.

Göral S. (2005). Türk Ermeni meselesi:  Mağduriyet psikolojisi ve büyük-grup kimliği. Stratejik Analiz  6:66:89-96.

Huberman L. (2000). Feodal Toplumdan Yirminci Yüzyıla. İstanbul, İletişim Yayınları.

Hudson V.M., Vore C.S. Vore, (2002). Dış politika analizinin dünü, bugünü ve yarını. Göka E. Kuşçu I. derleyenler. “luslararası İlişkilerin Psikolojisi” içinde. Ankara, ASAM Yayınları .

Kelman H., Fisher R. (2003). Conflict analysis and resolution. Sears D., Huddy L., Jervis R. derleyenler. “Oxford Handbook of Political Psychology” içinde. New York,  Oxford University Press,ss.316- 320.

Klein M. (1946). Notes on some schizoid mechanisms.  International Journal of Psychoanalysis  27: 99- 110.

Pirene H. (2002). Ortaçağ Kentleri. İstanbul, İletişim Yayınları .

Schöneberg U. (1987). Gruppenpsychologische Hintergründe der Fremdenangst und Fremdenfeindlichkeit. In: Ausländer und Massenmedien. Bestandsaufnahme und Perspektiven. Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung. Band 253, Bonn. (Aktaran Subaşı,  2002).

Subaşı, Ç. B. (2002).  1000’den 2000’e tarihsel süreç içinde Avrupa’da yabancı düşmanlığı. Stratejik Analiz  7: 27: 144-154

Volkan V.D. (1999). Kanbağı Etnik Gururdan Etnik Teröre. İstanbul, Bağlam Yayınları.

Volkan V.D. (2005). Uluslararası ilişkilerde psikanaliz ve psikanalizde uluslararası ilişkiler. “1. Psikanaliz ve diplomasi arası işbirliğinde engeller”  Stratejik Analiz  6:62:52-57.

Wagner U,  Zick A. (1993). Den Türken geht es besser als uns. In: Psychologie Heute 7. (Aktaran Subaşı,  2002).

Yerasimos S. (2002). Ne Mutlu Türk’üm Diyene. Yerasimos S. yayına hazırlayan. “Türkler: Doğu ve Batı, İslam ve Laiklik” içinde. İstanbul, Doruk yayınları, ss.15-57.

 

Turkey and Humanity: Being Clear Like Water, Being Exciting Like Water, and Being Saintly Like Water…

By Recep Ali Topçu – Adell Armature&Valve Factories Inc. | Chairman of the Board

Copyright photo by Levent Ağaoğlu, Danube River bank at Russe, Bulgaria.

 

Water as an inspiration in the journey of becoming a human being that leaves a mark …

There is a nice saying. Man becomes human when he is, not when he is born. Man is human to the extent that he is enlightened and enlightens the people around him. Every living thing wants to develop and evolve.

Life is a journey of evolution. Life is walking, life is development, life is entrusted. We always have a desire to rise materially and spiritually in life.

It is in our hands to improve our enlightenment process, our life journey. If we do not start by raising our own quality and building our own personality, we cannot do anything. So how can we be bright people? How can we light our way? What do bright people have in common? Who and what should we look for while determining our road map in our walk to light and enlightenment? Who should we sample from? How should we calibrate ourselves?

Right here, we encounter water, our indispensable source of life, our raw material, our essence. Water is indispensable for enlightening our spiritual world as well as our biological life. Our main ingredient. What can we learn from luminous water in order to be a bright person? Let’s try to find answers to these questions together, inspired by the water, our source of life, returning to our core values, making them valuable, feeling like water. I believe that it will not be very difficult to reveal these values ​​that are in our essence and to make them livable, and it will take us to the top of the steps of humanity, and will make us distance in the journey of the perfect human.

Regardless of where we are in this world where we are our guests, our priority should be to be a quality person once. One of the most beautiful sources of inspiration that we can take advantage of and learn from while achieving our goal of being a quality person is water. We know that water is one of the most important and beautiful gifts that our Almighty Creator has sent for us, the guests of the world. When we get to know him, we will realize that he has many lessons we will take.

There are many lessons we can learn from water …

Water is indispensable and the source of life. Man and all living things were created from water. The universe was raised with water. From time immemorial the reason for existence has been water. The survival of living beings also depends on water. It is the life water of the first tree planted. Water is the life elixir of the creature thirsty in the desert. Every drop of water is precious. No matter what we drink except water, we cannot quench our thirst. Creatures that lack water wither and lose their vitality. Drained trees die as well as deaths in humans. Like water, we must learn to penetrate the veins of people, bring it to life and be indispensable. What are we sources of as humans? Will people feel a lack if we leave our environment? I wonder which works and which operations cannot be completed without us? What solutions are we part of? By increasing our qualities, repositioning ourselves in terms of being valuable and valuing, will bring beauty to ourselves, our institutions, our country and the whole humanity.

Water, which is the source of life, is clear, transparent, clear, inside and out, its essence and word is one. Therefore, while we are going to our goal of being a quality person, it is necessary to be pure like water, to unite our inside-outside, our actions and our discourse, and to reach integrity. The way to ensure trust and stability is through the unity and integrity of internal and external action and discourse. Openness, transparency and reality are among the most important values ​​of today. Sincerity, sincerity is one of the most beautiful universal human values ​​that crystallize and clarify our world. The curtains do not act on the things behind them. Those who have these values ​​are valuable. It becomes worthless over time without values. The combination of discourse and action makes us valuable.

When the water comes, it makes you happy, when it leaves, it hurts. Its existence is the source of life. Everywhere the water steps is refreshed and beautiful. When it comes, it brings life to the thirsty plant, the thirsty animal in the desert, and the human being. With his arrival the joy skyrockets. Trees rejoice, celebrate, open their leaves, wear their green clothes. The earth rejoices and turns into a green cover. The seed rejoices and bursts out of the ground.

What should we, as humans, do to make us happy when we come and sadden when we go? Can we beautify the place where we take a step? The person who delights when he comes is oxygen, he is a positive, bright-spirited, bright-faced, energetic and decent person. It illuminates the place it comes from, the heart it enters, makes it happy, expands the atmosphere and makes everyone happy with its arrival, and leaves a mark when it leaves. However, people with negative spirits darken their environment and bored people and environments. Our dark world needs light people, bright faces and bright faces. When they go, they are happy and leave a work, not a trace. What can we add to where we come from? What do we leave when we go, trace or work?

Water is of good quality. The quality line is always the same. It is not variable. Sometimes it is, sometimes it is not. We should strive to carry this feature of our raw materials, we should have a personality with values ​​and definite lines.

Water beautifies the place it comes from, refreshes, enlivens, makes it green, makes it happy, and establishes civilization. Human beings have the task of beautifying their immediate surroundings, streets, avenues and our world, starting from within themselves just like water. When we question ourselves, are we a part of the beauty of the world or, on the contrary, are we in the problem, part of it?

The water does not disappear where it goes and comes from, after fulfilling its duty and responsibility, it evaporates and returns to where it came from, that is, the sky. As human beings, we can produce works and leave traces that will not disappear where we come and go.

Water has a memory, soul and consciousness. He understands the love and attention offered to him and gives a voice to it. Water receives positive and negative information around it and reacts accordingly. If the molecules of the water can distinguish between those who love and those who do not, we need to be a bridge between these people. If the water responds to what is said to him, is it possible that a person who is a piece of water does not respond to a beautiful word or sweet language? We say sweet tongue takes the snake out of its hole. Can we reflect the love given to us to the people and animals we have relationships with, and make them happy?

Can we act in the center of love, increase our capacity of love and include all people, animals, plants, nature and the environment in our scope?

Water is love, love, beloved. The water of our heartland is love. Dear people, nice words cherish people in hearts. A sip of love that we sincerely give to each other will return to us an armful. The fire of love in us wipes out all hate. It is nice to be a brick by using love as a mortar in the newly formed structure of the world. It is love that gives meaning to life.

The body where water is located is the source of warmth for its place. The human being is created as a drop of water, the human skin sensations carry warmth, providing warmth to the body as long as water is present. With death taking place and water withdrawing from the human body, the body cools, solidifies and hardens. It is the water that gives people warmth and vitality. We, too, must warm the way we enter into dialogue, the environments with our warm, heart and hypnotic expressions.

Water is generous, it always gives. By looking at the water, we should share some of what our Mawla gave us with other people, living things and plants, we should be generous.

Water is unifying, rejuvenating, water embracing. Since water is a community of people, animals and trees have been meeting and meeting points. Water does not discriminate between those who come to it, it is a democrat. He approaches everyone at an equal distance, has no prejudice. It provides unity in essence. Water does not discriminate against the people, living things and plants it serves, and behaves equally. Serving all people, animals and plants without distinction of color, language, religion, geography, and its balanced and harmonious behavior give a message of tolerance and uniting. When we treat all humanity and living things equally, we can be a winner just like water. Can we create a meeting point between our existence and people?

Continuity is essential in water. It is fluid, not broken. Water always flows and flows. It is the continuity of raindrops that makes streams into the world. Sometimes there are waves, sometimes drops, sometimes sweet, sometimes salty, it becomes rain, it becomes a river, it flows. When the drops accumulate, it becomes anticipated. In order for us to be successful as human beings, we must be stable, orderly and maintain continuity in our work and relationships that we feel like water. It is not the drops of water that pierces the marble, but its continuity.

Water flows, finds its way. It is important to find the right path. Roads are precious as life, gentle as life. They either consume life or add life to life. Some are straight, some are curved roads, some are deflecting roads, some are straight, some are curved roads. Every being has a way, every road has an end. The paths entered usually determine the results and the situation beyond. We can only become successful in life by taking the right way.

Water carries the energy of the source it originates from, the rock it touches, and the leaf it licks. Biologically, people have become a source of peace in their souls and souls with the energy they carry, as they are means of being. As human beings, which of the universal human values ​​do we carry, to whom do we charge energy?

Water is determined, does not tire, does not give up. If there is an infiltration even on the 10th floor in order to reach the land that it is in love with, how can it do it, eventually it will go down. Though the softest and thinnest, nothing can dissolve hard and hard things like large rocks as well as water. We will be more successful in life if we are determined, determined and willing in life. We don’t get stuck in small bumps and holes

The water has a natural beauty, it is sparkling. He is happy. It can be in three forms as solid, liquid and gas. Inspired by our essence, water, we should love our natural state given to us in creation and be happy with it. We should strive to live the beauty of living our lives with what we have and what is deemed appropriate for us, not caring about the physical characteristics of others.

Water is calm, dignified and saint. It is seated. His personality and stance are clear. Thinking we are water, as a drop of water, we can stand with our values ​​that make us who we are, calm, dignified and dignified. We can deserve to be saints like water.

The water is humble, its eyes are always below, it is in the ground. He wins with his humility. It does not stand above. As humans, the more we are humble, the more we can earn. Energy, love and good things always flow from top to bottom. Nothing will flow to us when we see ourselves above people. However, if we see ourselves inferior to other people and our interlocutors as required by our humanity and civilization, love, energy and knowledge will flow to us. The lower limit of civilization is to accept at least the same level as the other.

Although water is present in everything, many do not manifest themselves. It doesn’t stand out too much. He makes himself felt with what he does. We should be able to be different with the work we do with us, we should not make a lot of effort to make ourselves noticed, sometimes we need to stay in the background, learn to say we instead of me and reset our ego.

Water is mobile, it does not like stasis. It is always in motion. It evaporates from the sea, reaches the sky, becomes a river, flows, becomes a river. As soon as the water stops, they say it smells and makes worms. We, as human beings, must be active. We have a beautiful proverb called Where to move, there is abundance. Stasis is killing our cells. The moment we stop pressing the pedal of the bike, we fall. Then there is no stopping, continue the journey with love, enthusiasm and excitement.

“Water does not compete with anything, but it passes everything,” says the famous Chinese scholar Chuang Tzu. The wise person is like water, he is the person who does not compete with anyone but goes his own way, but because of this, he is superior to everyone.

Water carries the energy of the source where it was born and the way it came. Sometimes it pierces dams and mountains. As human beings, we must be energetic. We must always renew and develop our energy. Whether we are old or young, we must keep our souls young and energetic.

Water is flexible, finds its way, it reaches its destination at the end of the day. By looking at the water, our strength and our mind may be enough to align, to be flexible, to round our sharpness and angular directions, to be flexible.

Water has no pointed sides, so it has been continuing its journey in nature for years. When I picked up a handful of stones from an intermediate stream, although they were all different in color, size and style, they were always rounded and had no sharp points left. They were able to team up with their new structures and travel together to reach where I prevented them from traveling. In order to move forward in life, to be a team, to create a community in harmony, we can roll our sharp points without losing our basic features, and we should not hesitate to pay some costs during the journey.

Water knows how to stand upright without standing up. It exists in three forms in solid, liquid and gas states, but it cannot be compressed in any way in terms of volume. It fits the glass it enters, the container it enters, the environment it enters without losing its water properties. It takes the shape of it, it integrates with it. It does not cause any problems. But it certainly doesn’t come to squeeze. As humans, we have the qualities that can fit many environments. We have the ability to adapt to many environments without losing our values ​​and character.

Water is soft. It is hard, solid, not fragile. Nothing in the world is as soft and thin as water. In order to be successful in life, we must be mild-tempered with the lesson we learn from water, and we must knit our relationships with people based on softness and love, as Lao Tse says, “Nothing in the world is as soft and thin as water. But nothing can dissolve hard and stable things like large rocks as well as water. “

Water has no specific pattern. As human beings, we must be open to development, flexible and able to adapt to the environment we are in, with the lessons we learn from water. The abilities necessary for adaptation have been given to man in his creation.

The water is bright. When we see water in a dream, we interpret it for good. As human beings, we can make correct decisions and make choices to the extent that we increase our level of illumination. Each of us is light travelers, light seekers. As we increase our level of illumination, we will be more successful, we will reach higher steps in becoming a real human being and evolving with the structure that shines around. Our inner luminosity will reflect outside, with our face,

Water is the only blessing that can stand before the fire. It removes the heat. It extinguishes the anger. With the lesson we learn from water, we can extinguish angry people and act more sensibly.

Water is clean. Water begins its journey around the world immaculately. It does not absorb any pollution and does not contain any pollution. As he completes his journey and missions on our blue planet, evaporates and returns to the sky again, it is clean again. He always makes his journey purified and clean. In this world, where we came to be clean with birth, we should stay clean and continue our eternal journey cleanly. We should be purified from feelings such as hatred, hatred, selfishness and selfishness that pollute us, and replace them with feelings such as love, brotherhood, and tolerance.

It cleans the water. It cleans the place it touches, the objects it touches and the skin it touches, and it gives relief. As water cleans the dirt we see with the eyes, it cleanses the spiritual dirt, it relaxes us by taking the static electricity accumulated in our body. Because it is a cleanser, we tell the flowing water of the bad dreams we see in our dreams, we wait for it to take it away, we believe. It is water that prevents odors in toilets and toilets. For water, Muallim Naci says: “Water is a means of purifying both material and spiritual dirt. It is necessary for the cleansing of the soul and body. Water cleans everything, but it cannot clear disgrace. ”

As human beings, how much can we clean the people we touch, the places we touch, the environment we work in, and how clean can we keep?

Water is a source of healing. People with biological and psychological diseases have been healed from time to time with his warmth and sometimes with his voice. People who complain of constant headaches, your friends, most of these pains are caused by dehydration during the day. Drinking mineral water is the basis of being resistant to diseases. With the natural minerals in the water, we meet some of our body’s daily mineral needs. When we question ourselves, we wonder to whom, how much and when can we be healed with our existence, our approaches? Can we rid them of the issues and diseases they are uncomfortable with?

Water is the unity of differences. It was formed by the miraculous combination of two elements, which we can describe as fire and gunpowder, and reached a structure that purifies, gives peace and gives life. Here we see that elements of very different structures can come together if people wish, and they can create a much different, much stronger result by creating synergy.

Water helps the body and the living being that is bored, tired and sad. When we are bored or tired of reading, the first thing we do is to wash our faces. It brings water to our skin. Could we, as human beings, be able to cure the problems of the troubled people suffering from thirst and hunger in the world we live in, and to light the enlightenment of their darkness?

There is a perfect coincidence and cooperation between water molecules. They cling tightly to each other. They become a team. They don’t let each other go easily. It is as if they say, “There is mercy together, and there is torment in separation.” The glass is a few mm. excess water does not flow from there, it does not fall from there even though it is liquid because they hold on to each other. Can we humans hold on to each other as pieces of water, support each other like bricks in a building? We can be a team and make life better by holding each other tightly.

In this way, we make our lives easier. In fact, all of us living on the blue planet are a family together with all that is inside. Just as our hand in our body does not oppose our feet, we should be a part and complement of harmony, integrity in our home, workplace and world.

Until today, even a gram of water has not been produced or copied artificially. What superior values ​​and qualities do we have that make us who we are and cannot be reached and copied by humans? It is its values ​​that make the brand a brand. It is the spirit and values ​​that make human beings human. Those who do not have values, who do not live with their values ​​become worthless. Perhaps it is time for us to reposition ourselves, to gain new qualities. Starting from today, we can take action to gain ourselves new qualifications and values.

Water consists of two different elements, Hydrogen and oxygen, which are in conflict with each other and cannot be found together. One is fire and the other is gunpowder. However, water has combined these two different elements in such a way that a completely different drink has been formed. Here, we must learn to be together with different people in life, to head towards our goals together, to achieve success within differences.

Water is present and essence in everything in humans, animals, soil, fruits. However, it is invisible, does not make its presence felt. It has disappeared in the whole. It does not make an effort to be seen or felt. The river loses its presence in the sea, it does not make you feel. It becomes one with the sea, unites and integrates with the big part. Can we reset ourselves in the face of the life we ​​give to others when it comes to us? Can we stand back and render ourselves invisible? Can we rise from I consciousness to our consciousness?

Water is a mirror, reflects the energy, positive and negative thoughts loaded on it, and gives sound. Can we reflect the same approach in life to people who approach us with good intentions and positive thoughts? Can we even respond well to those who do evil, those who know?

Water is always giving, it tends to give rather than take. It is based on living rather than living. He seizes happiness in giving and eventually evaporates back to the sky he came from. People can find happiness only by giving, by living rather than living. He can attain peace with the virtue of giving.

Water is the source of greenery, the source of the environment. When talking about green factory, green product, can we be a green person like water, the source of greenery? Just as a green factory has some qualities that a green product should have, what qualifications should we have as a “green person”?

Those who drink spring water quench their thirst. Pınar never ends; because it experiences a process of harmony and movement with nature. We should never end, we should not experience failure syndrome.

As a result, there are many lessons and sources of inspiration that we can learn from water as people who are in a state of constant development and evolution. Looking a little more, you can see many similar sources of inspiration in your life. As you get to know water and love water, you can witness the existence of many dimensions.

Since our essence is water, these properties are present in us, our yeast and our raw materials. It should not be very difficult to reveal these beautiful qualities that fall on us as a drop of water, that are in our yeast, that are in our essence, that are put into us in our creation, and to turn them into our attributes. Now imagine that we are “water”, and we feel “like water”. Special like water, beautiful like water, clear like water, beneficial like water, indispensable like water, bright like water …

We can add light, tolerance and success to our lives by internalizing the beauties that can be inspired by water. We do not make excuses from Water, we can become more beautiful people with the lessons we take from it, and we can add beauty to the people we communicate with and our world. We can turn into a resource that distributes beauty like a transformer, and we can glorify our human qualities.

May your path be clear, your journey blessed and your light abundant. Be indispensable like water, living like water and saint like water.